Can I cast Thunderwave and be at the center of its bottom face, but not be affected by it? Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Planned maintenance scheduled April 17/18, 2019 at 00:00UTC (8:00pm US/Eastern) Time to retire the [rules-as-written] tag?Is Thunderwave centered on the caster?Spell Area of Effect RangeIs there a difference between cube areas-of-effect with Self or 5-feet ranges?Can a spell with a Cylinder area of effect have its point of origin higher than the listed height?Can you choose not to affect yourself with area of effect spells?What qualifies for the target of a spell?Range of dispel magic greater when used as area dispelWhat area does the Hallow spell actually cover?Can a cylinder-shaped spell be cast on air?Aiming a spell: GreaseHow does orienting a cube-shaped spell work in three-dimensional space?Does a persistent spell effect cast on a moving platform move with the platform, or is it fixed in space?Is there a difference between cube areas-of-effect with Self or 5-feet ranges?
Should I discuss the type of campaign with my players?
List *all* the tuples!
What causes the vertical darker bands in my photo?
Sorting numerically
Diagram with tikz
Were Kohanim forbidden from serving in King David's army?
Withdrew £2800, but only £2000 shows as withdrawn on online banking; what are my obligations?
How can I make names more distinctive without making them longer?
What LEGO pieces have "real-world" functionality?
What are the motives behind Cersei's orders given to Bronn?
Do you forfeit tax refunds/credits if you aren't required to and don't file by April 15?
How to deal with a team lead who never gives me credit?
iPhone Wallpaper?
What's the purpose of writing one's academic bio in 3rd person?
What are the pros and cons of Aerospike nosecones?
How to find all the available tools in macOS terminal?
Is a manifold-with-boundary with given interior and non-empty boundary essentially unique?
Letter Boxed validator
Is 1 ppb equal to 1 μg/kg?
Dating a Former Employee
Right-skewed distribution with mean equals to mode?
do i need a schengen visa for a direct flight to amsterdam?
Why did the IBM 650 use bi-quinary?
How does a Death Domain cleric's Touch of Death feature work with Touch-range spells delivered by familiars?
Can I cast Thunderwave and be at the center of its bottom face, but not be affected by it?
Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
Planned maintenance scheduled April 17/18, 2019 at 00:00UTC (8:00pm US/Eastern)
Time to retire the [rules-as-written] tag?Is Thunderwave centered on the caster?Spell Area of Effect RangeIs there a difference between cube areas-of-effect with Self or 5-feet ranges?Can a spell with a Cylinder area of effect have its point of origin higher than the listed height?Can you choose not to affect yourself with area of effect spells?What qualifies for the target of a spell?Range of dispel magic greater when used as area dispelWhat area does the Hallow spell actually cover?Can a cylinder-shaped spell be cast on air?Aiming a spell: GreaseHow does orienting a cube-shaped spell work in three-dimensional space?Does a persistent spell effect cast on a moving platform move with the platform, or is it fixed in space?Is there a difference between cube areas-of-effect with Self or 5-feet ranges?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
$begingroup$
Questions like this and this show that you cast Thunderwave as a cube, and you (the point of origin) stand at one of the cube's faces. From the PHB (emphasis mine):
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. [...] A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
If
- I'm on the ground
- I cast ThunderWave at ground level
- I choose to be at the center of the cube's bottom face
Can I choose not to be affected by the spell's area of effect?
So I could potentially explode and push 8 creatures away from me, without damaging myself.
dnd-5e spells area-of-effect
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Questions like this and this show that you cast Thunderwave as a cube, and you (the point of origin) stand at one of the cube's faces. From the PHB (emphasis mine):
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. [...] A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
If
- I'm on the ground
- I cast ThunderWave at ground level
- I choose to be at the center of the cube's bottom face
Can I choose not to be affected by the spell's area of effect?
So I could potentially explode and push 8 creatures away from me, without damaging myself.
dnd-5e spells area-of-effect
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
$endgroup$
2
$begingroup$
You should clarify whether you want to affect "adjacent" creatures that are "on the ground". The question in the title, and the bolded section, seem like a different question to the bolded section.
$endgroup$
– Andrzej Doyle
Apr 1 at 16:56
$begingroup$
@AndrzejDoyle Edited and added images for clarity
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:53
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Questions like this and this show that you cast Thunderwave as a cube, and you (the point of origin) stand at one of the cube's faces. From the PHB (emphasis mine):
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. [...] A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
If
- I'm on the ground
- I cast ThunderWave at ground level
- I choose to be at the center of the cube's bottom face
Can I choose not to be affected by the spell's area of effect?
So I could potentially explode and push 8 creatures away from me, without damaging myself.
dnd-5e spells area-of-effect
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
$endgroup$
Questions like this and this show that you cast Thunderwave as a cube, and you (the point of origin) stand at one of the cube's faces. From the PHB (emphasis mine):
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. [...] A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
If
- I'm on the ground
- I cast ThunderWave at ground level
- I choose to be at the center of the cube's bottom face
Can I choose not to be affected by the spell's area of effect?
So I could potentially explode and push 8 creatures away from me, without damaging myself.
dnd-5e spells area-of-effect
dnd-5e spells area-of-effect
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
edited Apr 2 at 15:53
BlueMoon93
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
asked Apr 1 at 12:35
BlueMoon93BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
16.1k1189158
2
$begingroup$
You should clarify whether you want to affect "adjacent" creatures that are "on the ground". The question in the title, and the bolded section, seem like a different question to the bolded section.
$endgroup$
– Andrzej Doyle
Apr 1 at 16:56
$begingroup$
@AndrzejDoyle Edited and added images for clarity
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:53
add a comment |
2
$begingroup$
You should clarify whether you want to affect "adjacent" creatures that are "on the ground". The question in the title, and the bolded section, seem like a different question to the bolded section.
$endgroup$
– Andrzej Doyle
Apr 1 at 16:56
$begingroup$
@AndrzejDoyle Edited and added images for clarity
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:53
2
2
$begingroup$
You should clarify whether you want to affect "adjacent" creatures that are "on the ground". The question in the title, and the bolded section, seem like a different question to the bolded section.
$endgroup$
– Andrzej Doyle
Apr 1 at 16:56
$begingroup$
You should clarify whether you want to affect "adjacent" creatures that are "on the ground". The question in the title, and the bolded section, seem like a different question to the bolded section.
$endgroup$
– Andrzej Doyle
Apr 1 at 16:56
$begingroup$
@AndrzejDoyle Edited and added images for clarity
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:53
$begingroup$
@AndrzejDoyle Edited and added images for clarity
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:53
add a comment |
5 Answers
5
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Unfortunately, no (with one possible exception).
Although this isn't the place to say perhaps, I think I have a slight contention with the answers to the related questions on whether the caster including themselves in the area of effect, is completely inside the area in the way portrayed. I see this more as just the point of origin affecting the caster (as it says) but not that the entire area of effect has shifted.
Typically this would be so the caster can affect himself with a beneficial effect, which is likely the intention. In other words, the area of effect projects out in front (see the diagram below), but the caster, right on the point of origin, can be affected or not.
xxx
cxxx
xxx
Nevertheless.
Even accepting the ruling given on the previous question, your scenario would only possibly work against larger creatures.
Either you are in the area and hence affected by the spell.
Or you are not, which would mean the only way you could be in the center square of a cubic area of effect, yet not affected, would be if the cube was above you (or below you if you were somehow flying?). In this case a DM may rule it would only affect creatures that are taller than you, and tall enough to be affected by the blast that has just gone off above your head.
Nahyn Oklauq points out that it would be possible to lie down and cast Thunderwave from the ground, hence affecting same-sized creatures. This is playing a bit fast and loose with the rules (which are really geared towards a 2D map rather than these kind of 3D shenanigans), so would probably be DM fiat as to whether he would allow it.
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
For your "Nevertheless", I would add another case : if the caster is prone (or go prone on purpose) and cast it from the ground, Medium and even Small creatures could be in the area. But that's only if the GM is okay with a bit of "tactical 3D combat" trickery
$endgroup$
– Nahyn Oklauq
Apr 1 at 15:15
1
$begingroup$
This would only work with GM Fiat ("because it makes sense"); you are not any lower (on a grid system) when prone than you would be standing. You still occupy the same 5ftx5ftx5ft 'box' and your range is unchanged.
$endgroup$
– Ifusaso
Apr 1 at 17:10
$begingroup$
I've edited the answer a bit (mostly grammar and style). Please revise. I think I will accept this, it was the most helpful for me, even if it didn't have the most upvotes
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:42
$begingroup$
Yes, that's fine. And totally accept Ifusaso's comment that the "lying prone" scenario would only work if the DM ignores the grid system (and this is really starting to drift from the intention of the spell IMHO)
$endgroup$
– PJRZ
Apr 2 at 15:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, assuming you are casting Thunderwave straight up
The spell states:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you. Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you...
And as you quoted from the PHB:
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
Together we can deduce that you (the caster) are the point of origin (from the spell), and the point of origin needs to be a point on a face of the cube (from the spellcasting section), and you can choose to include the point of origin in the spells effect or not (also from the spellcasting section).
Subject to your DMs philosophies on grid-maps, you can orient the 15ft cube of the spell in any direction you want, including straight up or down. If you choose the point of origin to be in the centre of a face (of the cube) creatures directly beside you (on the plane) would be inside the area of the effect and thus be subject to making the saving throw. Directing the cube to fill the 15ft of the air above you would catch creatures on your level and above, pushing them "10 feet away from you", as per the spell.
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Out of the box thinking to address a box-of-thunderwave going off above you. 3D FTW! Nice answer. Death to Stirges and Bats!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:24
4
$begingroup$
Would it really catch creatures on your level? Or just creatures above you? I guess it depends on whether the "point of origin" is defined to be a specific point (e.g. your fingertip) or the entire 5-foot cube that you occupy.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:16
1
$begingroup$
I guess you could fall prone, cast the spell, then stand back up.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:23
2
$begingroup$
I didn't understand how I can cast the cube above me, and creatures next to me on the ground are also affected. Can you clarify?
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 8:35
add a comment |
$begingroup$
No, and No
Firstly, thunderwave only specifies that it harms creatures in its area of effect (no other creatures):
Each creature in a 15-foot cube [...]
If you were to be in its area, then you would be subject to damage (and presumably the push effect). However and secondly, thunderwave repeatedly used the word from:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you.
Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you must make a Constitution saving throw.
(emphasis mine) This indicates that the cube must be pointed away from you, and so you can't put yourself into its area of effect.
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
If you're at the center, the cube can still originate from you, similar to a spherical explosion, don't you agree? Anyhow, I think you should make an answer with your argument on the questions I've linked, and narrow this answer to my question
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 13:29
$begingroup$
Except as you state in the question you are at its face, so for you (the point of origin) to be at its bottom face, the spell effect would be above you, and so only affect creatures that occupied more vertical space.
$endgroup$
– Someone_Evil
Apr 1 at 13:33
$begingroup$
Ah, you argue that I (the point of origin) must be outside the cube. I don't agree, but I understand your answer now
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 14:08
$begingroup$
(Edit was for some prose/usage corrections. Nicely reasoned answer. +1 ) :)
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:23
$begingroup$
Could "from" not mean "source?" That is, from the caster instead of originating from a point she can see in 30'? In this sense, couldn't the caster have the cube emanate (say) centered on/from her big toe upward?
$endgroup$
– Rykara
Apr 1 at 18:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, if you are a Storm Sorcerer at 18th level.
Wind Soul
At 18th level, you gain immunity to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
If you are a sixth level Storm Sorcerer, you have resistance to your own damage.
Heart of the Storm
At 6th level, you gain Resistance to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
You can maybe do it from the Top Face as a First Level Storm Sorcerer
Tempestuous Magic
Starting at 1st level, you can use a Bonus Action on Your Turn to cause whirling gusts of elemental air to briefly surround you, immediately before or after you Cast a Spell of 1st level or higher. Doing so allows you to fly up to 10 feet without provoking Opportunity Attacks. (XGtE)
This would work better when standing on a bridge or a ledge than on a hard floor.
But if, as you noted in comments, you are playing a wizard ...
Yes1 - if you are a Wizard(Evoker) of 2d level or higher.
The sculpt spells feature allows you to do this if you are a wizard of the evocation school.
Sculpt Spells
Beginning at 2nd level, you can create pockets of relative safety within the effects of your evocation spells. When you cast an evocation spell that affects other creatures that you can see, you can choose a number of them equal to 1 + the spell’s level. The chosen creatures automatically succeed on their saving throws against the spell, and they take no damage if they would normally take half damage on a successful save. (Basic Rules, p. 34)
You can see yourself, so you can include yourself in the protected zone.
On a failed save, a creature takes 2d8 thunder damage and is pushed 10
feet away from you.
As I don't see a way to push yourself away from yourself, the caster would not be subject to the pushing effect in this case.
1Caveat
@illustro points out that this interpretation may not fit RAW as strictly as possible, since "other" generally doesn't include one's self. While I think it fits - we can call that a RAF view of this feature - a given DM may take illustro's point on a strict reading of the rules and not allow sculpt spells to apply.
(FWIW, this did come up in a game where I was DM, and since the Wizard was an evoker, I allowed it since it makes sense to me. I can see the other ruling as well).
Rulings and Rules ...
Mike Mearls (one of the devs) is of the opinion that you can save yourself, but I have not found Jeremy Crawford's take on that question - his rulings are more authoritative than Mike's. Sculpt spells is not addressed in the most recent Sage Advice Compendium (version 2.3), nor in the PHB errata.
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
$endgroup$
2
$begingroup$
The Sculpt Spell ability only enables you to make other creatures save automatically, not yourself unfortunately. Though as a DM and RaF I'd allow it!
$endgroup$
– illustro
Apr 1 at 14:55
$begingroup$
@illustro I'll add your point as a caveat, thanks!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 14:56
add a comment |
$begingroup$
You can definitely include yourself
It is right in your cited explanation of cube range:
A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
That is akin to putting yourself in the range of the spell. Even if this were not the case, you could still have the origin outside the range, and have yourself in it.
You might be able to avoid damage, if and only if you are an Evocation Wizard
Evocation wizards can sculpt spells to avoid hitting allies. However, whether you can do this is subject to interpretation:
Sculpt Spells
... that affects other creatures you can see ...
(emphasis mine)
It is up to you and your DM whether other refers to non-target creatures or not yourself, but I believe it is the former.
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
$endgroup$
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "122"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f144271%2fcan-i-cast-thunderwave-and-be-at-the-center-of-its-bottom-face-but-not-be-affec%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
5 Answers
5
active
oldest
votes
5 Answers
5
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Unfortunately, no (with one possible exception).
Although this isn't the place to say perhaps, I think I have a slight contention with the answers to the related questions on whether the caster including themselves in the area of effect, is completely inside the area in the way portrayed. I see this more as just the point of origin affecting the caster (as it says) but not that the entire area of effect has shifted.
Typically this would be so the caster can affect himself with a beneficial effect, which is likely the intention. In other words, the area of effect projects out in front (see the diagram below), but the caster, right on the point of origin, can be affected or not.
xxx
cxxx
xxx
Nevertheless.
Even accepting the ruling given on the previous question, your scenario would only possibly work against larger creatures.
Either you are in the area and hence affected by the spell.
Or you are not, which would mean the only way you could be in the center square of a cubic area of effect, yet not affected, would be if the cube was above you (or below you if you were somehow flying?). In this case a DM may rule it would only affect creatures that are taller than you, and tall enough to be affected by the blast that has just gone off above your head.
Nahyn Oklauq points out that it would be possible to lie down and cast Thunderwave from the ground, hence affecting same-sized creatures. This is playing a bit fast and loose with the rules (which are really geared towards a 2D map rather than these kind of 3D shenanigans), so would probably be DM fiat as to whether he would allow it.
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
For your "Nevertheless", I would add another case : if the caster is prone (or go prone on purpose) and cast it from the ground, Medium and even Small creatures could be in the area. But that's only if the GM is okay with a bit of "tactical 3D combat" trickery
$endgroup$
– Nahyn Oklauq
Apr 1 at 15:15
1
$begingroup$
This would only work with GM Fiat ("because it makes sense"); you are not any lower (on a grid system) when prone than you would be standing. You still occupy the same 5ftx5ftx5ft 'box' and your range is unchanged.
$endgroup$
– Ifusaso
Apr 1 at 17:10
$begingroup$
I've edited the answer a bit (mostly grammar and style). Please revise. I think I will accept this, it was the most helpful for me, even if it didn't have the most upvotes
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:42
$begingroup$
Yes, that's fine. And totally accept Ifusaso's comment that the "lying prone" scenario would only work if the DM ignores the grid system (and this is really starting to drift from the intention of the spell IMHO)
$endgroup$
– PJRZ
Apr 2 at 15:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Unfortunately, no (with one possible exception).
Although this isn't the place to say perhaps, I think I have a slight contention with the answers to the related questions on whether the caster including themselves in the area of effect, is completely inside the area in the way portrayed. I see this more as just the point of origin affecting the caster (as it says) but not that the entire area of effect has shifted.
Typically this would be so the caster can affect himself with a beneficial effect, which is likely the intention. In other words, the area of effect projects out in front (see the diagram below), but the caster, right on the point of origin, can be affected or not.
xxx
cxxx
xxx
Nevertheless.
Even accepting the ruling given on the previous question, your scenario would only possibly work against larger creatures.
Either you are in the area and hence affected by the spell.
Or you are not, which would mean the only way you could be in the center square of a cubic area of effect, yet not affected, would be if the cube was above you (or below you if you were somehow flying?). In this case a DM may rule it would only affect creatures that are taller than you, and tall enough to be affected by the blast that has just gone off above your head.
Nahyn Oklauq points out that it would be possible to lie down and cast Thunderwave from the ground, hence affecting same-sized creatures. This is playing a bit fast and loose with the rules (which are really geared towards a 2D map rather than these kind of 3D shenanigans), so would probably be DM fiat as to whether he would allow it.
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
For your "Nevertheless", I would add another case : if the caster is prone (or go prone on purpose) and cast it from the ground, Medium and even Small creatures could be in the area. But that's only if the GM is okay with a bit of "tactical 3D combat" trickery
$endgroup$
– Nahyn Oklauq
Apr 1 at 15:15
1
$begingroup$
This would only work with GM Fiat ("because it makes sense"); you are not any lower (on a grid system) when prone than you would be standing. You still occupy the same 5ftx5ftx5ft 'box' and your range is unchanged.
$endgroup$
– Ifusaso
Apr 1 at 17:10
$begingroup$
I've edited the answer a bit (mostly grammar and style). Please revise. I think I will accept this, it was the most helpful for me, even if it didn't have the most upvotes
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:42
$begingroup$
Yes, that's fine. And totally accept Ifusaso's comment that the "lying prone" scenario would only work if the DM ignores the grid system (and this is really starting to drift from the intention of the spell IMHO)
$endgroup$
– PJRZ
Apr 2 at 15:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Unfortunately, no (with one possible exception).
Although this isn't the place to say perhaps, I think I have a slight contention with the answers to the related questions on whether the caster including themselves in the area of effect, is completely inside the area in the way portrayed. I see this more as just the point of origin affecting the caster (as it says) but not that the entire area of effect has shifted.
Typically this would be so the caster can affect himself with a beneficial effect, which is likely the intention. In other words, the area of effect projects out in front (see the diagram below), but the caster, right on the point of origin, can be affected or not.
xxx
cxxx
xxx
Nevertheless.
Even accepting the ruling given on the previous question, your scenario would only possibly work against larger creatures.
Either you are in the area and hence affected by the spell.
Or you are not, which would mean the only way you could be in the center square of a cubic area of effect, yet not affected, would be if the cube was above you (or below you if you were somehow flying?). In this case a DM may rule it would only affect creatures that are taller than you, and tall enough to be affected by the blast that has just gone off above your head.
Nahyn Oklauq points out that it would be possible to lie down and cast Thunderwave from the ground, hence affecting same-sized creatures. This is playing a bit fast and loose with the rules (which are really geared towards a 2D map rather than these kind of 3D shenanigans), so would probably be DM fiat as to whether he would allow it.
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
$endgroup$
Unfortunately, no (with one possible exception).
Although this isn't the place to say perhaps, I think I have a slight contention with the answers to the related questions on whether the caster including themselves in the area of effect, is completely inside the area in the way portrayed. I see this more as just the point of origin affecting the caster (as it says) but not that the entire area of effect has shifted.
Typically this would be so the caster can affect himself with a beneficial effect, which is likely the intention. In other words, the area of effect projects out in front (see the diagram below), but the caster, right on the point of origin, can be affected or not.
xxx
cxxx
xxx
Nevertheless.
Even accepting the ruling given on the previous question, your scenario would only possibly work against larger creatures.
Either you are in the area and hence affected by the spell.
Or you are not, which would mean the only way you could be in the center square of a cubic area of effect, yet not affected, would be if the cube was above you (or below you if you were somehow flying?). In this case a DM may rule it would only affect creatures that are taller than you, and tall enough to be affected by the blast that has just gone off above your head.
Nahyn Oklauq points out that it would be possible to lie down and cast Thunderwave from the ground, hence affecting same-sized creatures. This is playing a bit fast and loose with the rules (which are really geared towards a 2D map rather than these kind of 3D shenanigans), so would probably be DM fiat as to whether he would allow it.
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
edited Apr 2 at 15:42
BlueMoon93
16.1k1189158
16.1k1189158
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
answered Apr 1 at 13:22
PJRZPJRZ
12.6k14059
12.6k14059
1
$begingroup$
For your "Nevertheless", I would add another case : if the caster is prone (or go prone on purpose) and cast it from the ground, Medium and even Small creatures could be in the area. But that's only if the GM is okay with a bit of "tactical 3D combat" trickery
$endgroup$
– Nahyn Oklauq
Apr 1 at 15:15
1
$begingroup$
This would only work with GM Fiat ("because it makes sense"); you are not any lower (on a grid system) when prone than you would be standing. You still occupy the same 5ftx5ftx5ft 'box' and your range is unchanged.
$endgroup$
– Ifusaso
Apr 1 at 17:10
$begingroup$
I've edited the answer a bit (mostly grammar and style). Please revise. I think I will accept this, it was the most helpful for me, even if it didn't have the most upvotes
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:42
$begingroup$
Yes, that's fine. And totally accept Ifusaso's comment that the "lying prone" scenario would only work if the DM ignores the grid system (and this is really starting to drift from the intention of the spell IMHO)
$endgroup$
– PJRZ
Apr 2 at 15:55
add a comment |
1
$begingroup$
For your "Nevertheless", I would add another case : if the caster is prone (or go prone on purpose) and cast it from the ground, Medium and even Small creatures could be in the area. But that's only if the GM is okay with a bit of "tactical 3D combat" trickery
$endgroup$
– Nahyn Oklauq
Apr 1 at 15:15
1
$begingroup$
This would only work with GM Fiat ("because it makes sense"); you are not any lower (on a grid system) when prone than you would be standing. You still occupy the same 5ftx5ftx5ft 'box' and your range is unchanged.
$endgroup$
– Ifusaso
Apr 1 at 17:10
$begingroup$
I've edited the answer a bit (mostly grammar and style). Please revise. I think I will accept this, it was the most helpful for me, even if it didn't have the most upvotes
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:42
$begingroup$
Yes, that's fine. And totally accept Ifusaso's comment that the "lying prone" scenario would only work if the DM ignores the grid system (and this is really starting to drift from the intention of the spell IMHO)
$endgroup$
– PJRZ
Apr 2 at 15:55
1
1
$begingroup$
For your "Nevertheless", I would add another case : if the caster is prone (or go prone on purpose) and cast it from the ground, Medium and even Small creatures could be in the area. But that's only if the GM is okay with a bit of "tactical 3D combat" trickery
$endgroup$
– Nahyn Oklauq
Apr 1 at 15:15
$begingroup$
For your "Nevertheless", I would add another case : if the caster is prone (or go prone on purpose) and cast it from the ground, Medium and even Small creatures could be in the area. But that's only if the GM is okay with a bit of "tactical 3D combat" trickery
$endgroup$
– Nahyn Oklauq
Apr 1 at 15:15
1
1
$begingroup$
This would only work with GM Fiat ("because it makes sense"); you are not any lower (on a grid system) when prone than you would be standing. You still occupy the same 5ftx5ftx5ft 'box' and your range is unchanged.
$endgroup$
– Ifusaso
Apr 1 at 17:10
$begingroup$
This would only work with GM Fiat ("because it makes sense"); you are not any lower (on a grid system) when prone than you would be standing. You still occupy the same 5ftx5ftx5ft 'box' and your range is unchanged.
$endgroup$
– Ifusaso
Apr 1 at 17:10
$begingroup$
I've edited the answer a bit (mostly grammar and style). Please revise. I think I will accept this, it was the most helpful for me, even if it didn't have the most upvotes
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:42
$begingroup$
I've edited the answer a bit (mostly grammar and style). Please revise. I think I will accept this, it was the most helpful for me, even if it didn't have the most upvotes
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:42
$begingroup$
Yes, that's fine. And totally accept Ifusaso's comment that the "lying prone" scenario would only work if the DM ignores the grid system (and this is really starting to drift from the intention of the spell IMHO)
$endgroup$
– PJRZ
Apr 2 at 15:55
$begingroup$
Yes, that's fine. And totally accept Ifusaso's comment that the "lying prone" scenario would only work if the DM ignores the grid system (and this is really starting to drift from the intention of the spell IMHO)
$endgroup$
– PJRZ
Apr 2 at 15:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, assuming you are casting Thunderwave straight up
The spell states:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you. Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you...
And as you quoted from the PHB:
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
Together we can deduce that you (the caster) are the point of origin (from the spell), and the point of origin needs to be a point on a face of the cube (from the spellcasting section), and you can choose to include the point of origin in the spells effect or not (also from the spellcasting section).
Subject to your DMs philosophies on grid-maps, you can orient the 15ft cube of the spell in any direction you want, including straight up or down. If you choose the point of origin to be in the centre of a face (of the cube) creatures directly beside you (on the plane) would be inside the area of the effect and thus be subject to making the saving throw. Directing the cube to fill the 15ft of the air above you would catch creatures on your level and above, pushing them "10 feet away from you", as per the spell.
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Out of the box thinking to address a box-of-thunderwave going off above you. 3D FTW! Nice answer. Death to Stirges and Bats!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:24
4
$begingroup$
Would it really catch creatures on your level? Or just creatures above you? I guess it depends on whether the "point of origin" is defined to be a specific point (e.g. your fingertip) or the entire 5-foot cube that you occupy.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:16
1
$begingroup$
I guess you could fall prone, cast the spell, then stand back up.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:23
2
$begingroup$
I didn't understand how I can cast the cube above me, and creatures next to me on the ground are also affected. Can you clarify?
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 8:35
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, assuming you are casting Thunderwave straight up
The spell states:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you. Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you...
And as you quoted from the PHB:
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
Together we can deduce that you (the caster) are the point of origin (from the spell), and the point of origin needs to be a point on a face of the cube (from the spellcasting section), and you can choose to include the point of origin in the spells effect or not (also from the spellcasting section).
Subject to your DMs philosophies on grid-maps, you can orient the 15ft cube of the spell in any direction you want, including straight up or down. If you choose the point of origin to be in the centre of a face (of the cube) creatures directly beside you (on the plane) would be inside the area of the effect and thus be subject to making the saving throw. Directing the cube to fill the 15ft of the air above you would catch creatures on your level and above, pushing them "10 feet away from you", as per the spell.
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Out of the box thinking to address a box-of-thunderwave going off above you. 3D FTW! Nice answer. Death to Stirges and Bats!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:24
4
$begingroup$
Would it really catch creatures on your level? Or just creatures above you? I guess it depends on whether the "point of origin" is defined to be a specific point (e.g. your fingertip) or the entire 5-foot cube that you occupy.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:16
1
$begingroup$
I guess you could fall prone, cast the spell, then stand back up.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:23
2
$begingroup$
I didn't understand how I can cast the cube above me, and creatures next to me on the ground are also affected. Can you clarify?
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 8:35
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, assuming you are casting Thunderwave straight up
The spell states:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you. Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you...
And as you quoted from the PHB:
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
Together we can deduce that you (the caster) are the point of origin (from the spell), and the point of origin needs to be a point on a face of the cube (from the spellcasting section), and you can choose to include the point of origin in the spells effect or not (also from the spellcasting section).
Subject to your DMs philosophies on grid-maps, you can orient the 15ft cube of the spell in any direction you want, including straight up or down. If you choose the point of origin to be in the centre of a face (of the cube) creatures directly beside you (on the plane) would be inside the area of the effect and thus be subject to making the saving throw. Directing the cube to fill the 15ft of the air above you would catch creatures on your level and above, pushing them "10 feet away from you", as per the spell.
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
$endgroup$
Yes, assuming you are casting Thunderwave straight up
The spell states:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you. Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you...
And as you quoted from the PHB:
You select a cube's point of origin, which lies anywhere on a face of the cubic effect. A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
Together we can deduce that you (the caster) are the point of origin (from the spell), and the point of origin needs to be a point on a face of the cube (from the spellcasting section), and you can choose to include the point of origin in the spells effect or not (also from the spellcasting section).
Subject to your DMs philosophies on grid-maps, you can orient the 15ft cube of the spell in any direction you want, including straight up or down. If you choose the point of origin to be in the centre of a face (of the cube) creatures directly beside you (on the plane) would be inside the area of the effect and thus be subject to making the saving throw. Directing the cube to fill the 15ft of the air above you would catch creatures on your level and above, pushing them "10 feet away from you", as per the spell.
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
answered Apr 1 at 15:21
GreySageGreySage
16.3k453100
16.3k453100
$begingroup$
Out of the box thinking to address a box-of-thunderwave going off above you. 3D FTW! Nice answer. Death to Stirges and Bats!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:24
4
$begingroup$
Would it really catch creatures on your level? Or just creatures above you? I guess it depends on whether the "point of origin" is defined to be a specific point (e.g. your fingertip) or the entire 5-foot cube that you occupy.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:16
1
$begingroup$
I guess you could fall prone, cast the spell, then stand back up.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:23
2
$begingroup$
I didn't understand how I can cast the cube above me, and creatures next to me on the ground are also affected. Can you clarify?
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 8:35
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Out of the box thinking to address a box-of-thunderwave going off above you. 3D FTW! Nice answer. Death to Stirges and Bats!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:24
4
$begingroup$
Would it really catch creatures on your level? Or just creatures above you? I guess it depends on whether the "point of origin" is defined to be a specific point (e.g. your fingertip) or the entire 5-foot cube that you occupy.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:16
1
$begingroup$
I guess you could fall prone, cast the spell, then stand back up.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:23
2
$begingroup$
I didn't understand how I can cast the cube above me, and creatures next to me on the ground are also affected. Can you clarify?
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 8:35
$begingroup$
Out of the box thinking to address a box-of-thunderwave going off above you. 3D FTW! Nice answer. Death to Stirges and Bats!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:24
$begingroup$
Out of the box thinking to address a box-of-thunderwave going off above you. 3D FTW! Nice answer. Death to Stirges and Bats!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:24
4
4
$begingroup$
Would it really catch creatures on your level? Or just creatures above you? I guess it depends on whether the "point of origin" is defined to be a specific point (e.g. your fingertip) or the entire 5-foot cube that you occupy.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:16
$begingroup$
Would it really catch creatures on your level? Or just creatures above you? I guess it depends on whether the "point of origin" is defined to be a specific point (e.g. your fingertip) or the entire 5-foot cube that you occupy.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:16
1
1
$begingroup$
I guess you could fall prone, cast the spell, then stand back up.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:23
$begingroup$
I guess you could fall prone, cast the spell, then stand back up.
$endgroup$
– Ryan Thompson
Apr 1 at 17:23
2
2
$begingroup$
I didn't understand how I can cast the cube above me, and creatures next to me on the ground are also affected. Can you clarify?
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 8:35
$begingroup$
I didn't understand how I can cast the cube above me, and creatures next to me on the ground are also affected. Can you clarify?
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 8:35
add a comment |
$begingroup$
No, and No
Firstly, thunderwave only specifies that it harms creatures in its area of effect (no other creatures):
Each creature in a 15-foot cube [...]
If you were to be in its area, then you would be subject to damage (and presumably the push effect). However and secondly, thunderwave repeatedly used the word from:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you.
Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you must make a Constitution saving throw.
(emphasis mine) This indicates that the cube must be pointed away from you, and so you can't put yourself into its area of effect.
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
If you're at the center, the cube can still originate from you, similar to a spherical explosion, don't you agree? Anyhow, I think you should make an answer with your argument on the questions I've linked, and narrow this answer to my question
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 13:29
$begingroup$
Except as you state in the question you are at its face, so for you (the point of origin) to be at its bottom face, the spell effect would be above you, and so only affect creatures that occupied more vertical space.
$endgroup$
– Someone_Evil
Apr 1 at 13:33
$begingroup$
Ah, you argue that I (the point of origin) must be outside the cube. I don't agree, but I understand your answer now
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 14:08
$begingroup$
(Edit was for some prose/usage corrections. Nicely reasoned answer. +1 ) :)
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:23
$begingroup$
Could "from" not mean "source?" That is, from the caster instead of originating from a point she can see in 30'? In this sense, couldn't the caster have the cube emanate (say) centered on/from her big toe upward?
$endgroup$
– Rykara
Apr 1 at 18:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
No, and No
Firstly, thunderwave only specifies that it harms creatures in its area of effect (no other creatures):
Each creature in a 15-foot cube [...]
If you were to be in its area, then you would be subject to damage (and presumably the push effect). However and secondly, thunderwave repeatedly used the word from:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you.
Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you must make a Constitution saving throw.
(emphasis mine) This indicates that the cube must be pointed away from you, and so you can't put yourself into its area of effect.
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
If you're at the center, the cube can still originate from you, similar to a spherical explosion, don't you agree? Anyhow, I think you should make an answer with your argument on the questions I've linked, and narrow this answer to my question
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 13:29
$begingroup$
Except as you state in the question you are at its face, so for you (the point of origin) to be at its bottom face, the spell effect would be above you, and so only affect creatures that occupied more vertical space.
$endgroup$
– Someone_Evil
Apr 1 at 13:33
$begingroup$
Ah, you argue that I (the point of origin) must be outside the cube. I don't agree, but I understand your answer now
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 14:08
$begingroup$
(Edit was for some prose/usage corrections. Nicely reasoned answer. +1 ) :)
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:23
$begingroup$
Could "from" not mean "source?" That is, from the caster instead of originating from a point she can see in 30'? In this sense, couldn't the caster have the cube emanate (say) centered on/from her big toe upward?
$endgroup$
– Rykara
Apr 1 at 18:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
No, and No
Firstly, thunderwave only specifies that it harms creatures in its area of effect (no other creatures):
Each creature in a 15-foot cube [...]
If you were to be in its area, then you would be subject to damage (and presumably the push effect). However and secondly, thunderwave repeatedly used the word from:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you.
Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you must make a Constitution saving throw.
(emphasis mine) This indicates that the cube must be pointed away from you, and so you can't put yourself into its area of effect.
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
$endgroup$
No, and No
Firstly, thunderwave only specifies that it harms creatures in its area of effect (no other creatures):
Each creature in a 15-foot cube [...]
If you were to be in its area, then you would be subject to damage (and presumably the push effect). However and secondly, thunderwave repeatedly used the word from:
A wave of thunderous force sweeps out from you.
Each creature in a 15-foot cube originating from you must make a Constitution saving throw.
(emphasis mine) This indicates that the cube must be pointed away from you, and so you can't put yourself into its area of effect.
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
edited Apr 1 at 15:31
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
answered Apr 1 at 13:21
Someone_EvilSomeone_Evil
2,522626
2,522626
$begingroup$
If you're at the center, the cube can still originate from you, similar to a spherical explosion, don't you agree? Anyhow, I think you should make an answer with your argument on the questions I've linked, and narrow this answer to my question
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 13:29
$begingroup$
Except as you state in the question you are at its face, so for you (the point of origin) to be at its bottom face, the spell effect would be above you, and so only affect creatures that occupied more vertical space.
$endgroup$
– Someone_Evil
Apr 1 at 13:33
$begingroup$
Ah, you argue that I (the point of origin) must be outside the cube. I don't agree, but I understand your answer now
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 14:08
$begingroup$
(Edit was for some prose/usage corrections. Nicely reasoned answer. +1 ) :)
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:23
$begingroup$
Could "from" not mean "source?" That is, from the caster instead of originating from a point she can see in 30'? In this sense, couldn't the caster have the cube emanate (say) centered on/from her big toe upward?
$endgroup$
– Rykara
Apr 1 at 18:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
If you're at the center, the cube can still originate from you, similar to a spherical explosion, don't you agree? Anyhow, I think you should make an answer with your argument on the questions I've linked, and narrow this answer to my question
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 13:29
$begingroup$
Except as you state in the question you are at its face, so for you (the point of origin) to be at its bottom face, the spell effect would be above you, and so only affect creatures that occupied more vertical space.
$endgroup$
– Someone_Evil
Apr 1 at 13:33
$begingroup$
Ah, you argue that I (the point of origin) must be outside the cube. I don't agree, but I understand your answer now
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 14:08
$begingroup$
(Edit was for some prose/usage corrections. Nicely reasoned answer. +1 ) :)
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:23
$begingroup$
Could "from" not mean "source?" That is, from the caster instead of originating from a point she can see in 30'? In this sense, couldn't the caster have the cube emanate (say) centered on/from her big toe upward?
$endgroup$
– Rykara
Apr 1 at 18:55
$begingroup$
If you're at the center, the cube can still originate from you, similar to a spherical explosion, don't you agree? Anyhow, I think you should make an answer with your argument on the questions I've linked, and narrow this answer to my question
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 13:29
$begingroup$
If you're at the center, the cube can still originate from you, similar to a spherical explosion, don't you agree? Anyhow, I think you should make an answer with your argument on the questions I've linked, and narrow this answer to my question
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 13:29
$begingroup$
Except as you state in the question you are at its face, so for you (the point of origin) to be at its bottom face, the spell effect would be above you, and so only affect creatures that occupied more vertical space.
$endgroup$
– Someone_Evil
Apr 1 at 13:33
$begingroup$
Except as you state in the question you are at its face, so for you (the point of origin) to be at its bottom face, the spell effect would be above you, and so only affect creatures that occupied more vertical space.
$endgroup$
– Someone_Evil
Apr 1 at 13:33
$begingroup$
Ah, you argue that I (the point of origin) must be outside the cube. I don't agree, but I understand your answer now
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 14:08
$begingroup$
Ah, you argue that I (the point of origin) must be outside the cube. I don't agree, but I understand your answer now
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 1 at 14:08
$begingroup$
(Edit was for some prose/usage corrections. Nicely reasoned answer. +1 ) :)
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:23
$begingroup$
(Edit was for some prose/usage corrections. Nicely reasoned answer. +1 ) :)
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 15:23
$begingroup$
Could "from" not mean "source?" That is, from the caster instead of originating from a point she can see in 30'? In this sense, couldn't the caster have the cube emanate (say) centered on/from her big toe upward?
$endgroup$
– Rykara
Apr 1 at 18:55
$begingroup$
Could "from" not mean "source?" That is, from the caster instead of originating from a point she can see in 30'? In this sense, couldn't the caster have the cube emanate (say) centered on/from her big toe upward?
$endgroup$
– Rykara
Apr 1 at 18:55
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, if you are a Storm Sorcerer at 18th level.
Wind Soul
At 18th level, you gain immunity to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
If you are a sixth level Storm Sorcerer, you have resistance to your own damage.
Heart of the Storm
At 6th level, you gain Resistance to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
You can maybe do it from the Top Face as a First Level Storm Sorcerer
Tempestuous Magic
Starting at 1st level, you can use a Bonus Action on Your Turn to cause whirling gusts of elemental air to briefly surround you, immediately before or after you Cast a Spell of 1st level or higher. Doing so allows you to fly up to 10 feet without provoking Opportunity Attacks. (XGtE)
This would work better when standing on a bridge or a ledge than on a hard floor.
But if, as you noted in comments, you are playing a wizard ...
Yes1 - if you are a Wizard(Evoker) of 2d level or higher.
The sculpt spells feature allows you to do this if you are a wizard of the evocation school.
Sculpt Spells
Beginning at 2nd level, you can create pockets of relative safety within the effects of your evocation spells. When you cast an evocation spell that affects other creatures that you can see, you can choose a number of them equal to 1 + the spell’s level. The chosen creatures automatically succeed on their saving throws against the spell, and they take no damage if they would normally take half damage on a successful save. (Basic Rules, p. 34)
You can see yourself, so you can include yourself in the protected zone.
On a failed save, a creature takes 2d8 thunder damage and is pushed 10
feet away from you.
As I don't see a way to push yourself away from yourself, the caster would not be subject to the pushing effect in this case.
1Caveat
@illustro points out that this interpretation may not fit RAW as strictly as possible, since "other" generally doesn't include one's self. While I think it fits - we can call that a RAF view of this feature - a given DM may take illustro's point on a strict reading of the rules and not allow sculpt spells to apply.
(FWIW, this did come up in a game where I was DM, and since the Wizard was an evoker, I allowed it since it makes sense to me. I can see the other ruling as well).
Rulings and Rules ...
Mike Mearls (one of the devs) is of the opinion that you can save yourself, but I have not found Jeremy Crawford's take on that question - his rulings are more authoritative than Mike's. Sculpt spells is not addressed in the most recent Sage Advice Compendium (version 2.3), nor in the PHB errata.
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
$endgroup$
2
$begingroup$
The Sculpt Spell ability only enables you to make other creatures save automatically, not yourself unfortunately. Though as a DM and RaF I'd allow it!
$endgroup$
– illustro
Apr 1 at 14:55
$begingroup$
@illustro I'll add your point as a caveat, thanks!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 14:56
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, if you are a Storm Sorcerer at 18th level.
Wind Soul
At 18th level, you gain immunity to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
If you are a sixth level Storm Sorcerer, you have resistance to your own damage.
Heart of the Storm
At 6th level, you gain Resistance to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
You can maybe do it from the Top Face as a First Level Storm Sorcerer
Tempestuous Magic
Starting at 1st level, you can use a Bonus Action on Your Turn to cause whirling gusts of elemental air to briefly surround you, immediately before or after you Cast a Spell of 1st level or higher. Doing so allows you to fly up to 10 feet without provoking Opportunity Attacks. (XGtE)
This would work better when standing on a bridge or a ledge than on a hard floor.
But if, as you noted in comments, you are playing a wizard ...
Yes1 - if you are a Wizard(Evoker) of 2d level or higher.
The sculpt spells feature allows you to do this if you are a wizard of the evocation school.
Sculpt Spells
Beginning at 2nd level, you can create pockets of relative safety within the effects of your evocation spells. When you cast an evocation spell that affects other creatures that you can see, you can choose a number of them equal to 1 + the spell’s level. The chosen creatures automatically succeed on their saving throws against the spell, and they take no damage if they would normally take half damage on a successful save. (Basic Rules, p. 34)
You can see yourself, so you can include yourself in the protected zone.
On a failed save, a creature takes 2d8 thunder damage and is pushed 10
feet away from you.
As I don't see a way to push yourself away from yourself, the caster would not be subject to the pushing effect in this case.
1Caveat
@illustro points out that this interpretation may not fit RAW as strictly as possible, since "other" generally doesn't include one's self. While I think it fits - we can call that a RAF view of this feature - a given DM may take illustro's point on a strict reading of the rules and not allow sculpt spells to apply.
(FWIW, this did come up in a game where I was DM, and since the Wizard was an evoker, I allowed it since it makes sense to me. I can see the other ruling as well).
Rulings and Rules ...
Mike Mearls (one of the devs) is of the opinion that you can save yourself, but I have not found Jeremy Crawford's take on that question - his rulings are more authoritative than Mike's. Sculpt spells is not addressed in the most recent Sage Advice Compendium (version 2.3), nor in the PHB errata.
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
$endgroup$
2
$begingroup$
The Sculpt Spell ability only enables you to make other creatures save automatically, not yourself unfortunately. Though as a DM and RaF I'd allow it!
$endgroup$
– illustro
Apr 1 at 14:55
$begingroup$
@illustro I'll add your point as a caveat, thanks!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 14:56
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Yes, if you are a Storm Sorcerer at 18th level.
Wind Soul
At 18th level, you gain immunity to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
If you are a sixth level Storm Sorcerer, you have resistance to your own damage.
Heart of the Storm
At 6th level, you gain Resistance to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
You can maybe do it from the Top Face as a First Level Storm Sorcerer
Tempestuous Magic
Starting at 1st level, you can use a Bonus Action on Your Turn to cause whirling gusts of elemental air to briefly surround you, immediately before or after you Cast a Spell of 1st level or higher. Doing so allows you to fly up to 10 feet without provoking Opportunity Attacks. (XGtE)
This would work better when standing on a bridge or a ledge than on a hard floor.
But if, as you noted in comments, you are playing a wizard ...
Yes1 - if you are a Wizard(Evoker) of 2d level or higher.
The sculpt spells feature allows you to do this if you are a wizard of the evocation school.
Sculpt Spells
Beginning at 2nd level, you can create pockets of relative safety within the effects of your evocation spells. When you cast an evocation spell that affects other creatures that you can see, you can choose a number of them equal to 1 + the spell’s level. The chosen creatures automatically succeed on their saving throws against the spell, and they take no damage if they would normally take half damage on a successful save. (Basic Rules, p. 34)
You can see yourself, so you can include yourself in the protected zone.
On a failed save, a creature takes 2d8 thunder damage and is pushed 10
feet away from you.
As I don't see a way to push yourself away from yourself, the caster would not be subject to the pushing effect in this case.
1Caveat
@illustro points out that this interpretation may not fit RAW as strictly as possible, since "other" generally doesn't include one's self. While I think it fits - we can call that a RAF view of this feature - a given DM may take illustro's point on a strict reading of the rules and not allow sculpt spells to apply.
(FWIW, this did come up in a game where I was DM, and since the Wizard was an evoker, I allowed it since it makes sense to me. I can see the other ruling as well).
Rulings and Rules ...
Mike Mearls (one of the devs) is of the opinion that you can save yourself, but I have not found Jeremy Crawford's take on that question - his rulings are more authoritative than Mike's. Sculpt spells is not addressed in the most recent Sage Advice Compendium (version 2.3), nor in the PHB errata.
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
$endgroup$
Yes, if you are a Storm Sorcerer at 18th level.
Wind Soul
At 18th level, you gain immunity to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
If you are a sixth level Storm Sorcerer, you have resistance to your own damage.
Heart of the Storm
At 6th level, you gain Resistance to lightning and thunder damage. (XGtE)
You can maybe do it from the Top Face as a First Level Storm Sorcerer
Tempestuous Magic
Starting at 1st level, you can use a Bonus Action on Your Turn to cause whirling gusts of elemental air to briefly surround you, immediately before or after you Cast a Spell of 1st level or higher. Doing so allows you to fly up to 10 feet without provoking Opportunity Attacks. (XGtE)
This would work better when standing on a bridge or a ledge than on a hard floor.
But if, as you noted in comments, you are playing a wizard ...
Yes1 - if you are a Wizard(Evoker) of 2d level or higher.
The sculpt spells feature allows you to do this if you are a wizard of the evocation school.
Sculpt Spells
Beginning at 2nd level, you can create pockets of relative safety within the effects of your evocation spells. When you cast an evocation spell that affects other creatures that you can see, you can choose a number of them equal to 1 + the spell’s level. The chosen creatures automatically succeed on their saving throws against the spell, and they take no damage if they would normally take half damage on a successful save. (Basic Rules, p. 34)
You can see yourself, so you can include yourself in the protected zone.
On a failed save, a creature takes 2d8 thunder damage and is pushed 10
feet away from you.
As I don't see a way to push yourself away from yourself, the caster would not be subject to the pushing effect in this case.
1Caveat
@illustro points out that this interpretation may not fit RAW as strictly as possible, since "other" generally doesn't include one's self. While I think it fits - we can call that a RAF view of this feature - a given DM may take illustro's point on a strict reading of the rules and not allow sculpt spells to apply.
(FWIW, this did come up in a game where I was DM, and since the Wizard was an evoker, I allowed it since it makes sense to me. I can see the other ruling as well).
Rulings and Rules ...
Mike Mearls (one of the devs) is of the opinion that you can save yourself, but I have not found Jeremy Crawford's take on that question - his rulings are more authoritative than Mike's. Sculpt spells is not addressed in the most recent Sage Advice Compendium (version 2.3), nor in the PHB errata.
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
edited Apr 1 at 15:41
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
answered Apr 1 at 14:53
KorvinStarmastKorvinStarmast
84k20261456
84k20261456
2
$begingroup$
The Sculpt Spell ability only enables you to make other creatures save automatically, not yourself unfortunately. Though as a DM and RaF I'd allow it!
$endgroup$
– illustro
Apr 1 at 14:55
$begingroup$
@illustro I'll add your point as a caveat, thanks!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 14:56
add a comment |
2
$begingroup$
The Sculpt Spell ability only enables you to make other creatures save automatically, not yourself unfortunately. Though as a DM and RaF I'd allow it!
$endgroup$
– illustro
Apr 1 at 14:55
$begingroup$
@illustro I'll add your point as a caveat, thanks!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 14:56
2
2
$begingroup$
The Sculpt Spell ability only enables you to make other creatures save automatically, not yourself unfortunately. Though as a DM and RaF I'd allow it!
$endgroup$
– illustro
Apr 1 at 14:55
$begingroup$
The Sculpt Spell ability only enables you to make other creatures save automatically, not yourself unfortunately. Though as a DM and RaF I'd allow it!
$endgroup$
– illustro
Apr 1 at 14:55
$begingroup$
@illustro I'll add your point as a caveat, thanks!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 14:56
$begingroup$
@illustro I'll add your point as a caveat, thanks!
$endgroup$
– KorvinStarmast
Apr 1 at 14:56
add a comment |
$begingroup$
You can definitely include yourself
It is right in your cited explanation of cube range:
A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
That is akin to putting yourself in the range of the spell. Even if this were not the case, you could still have the origin outside the range, and have yourself in it.
You might be able to avoid damage, if and only if you are an Evocation Wizard
Evocation wizards can sculpt spells to avoid hitting allies. However, whether you can do this is subject to interpretation:
Sculpt Spells
... that affects other creatures you can see ...
(emphasis mine)
It is up to you and your DM whether other refers to non-target creatures or not yourself, but I believe it is the former.
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
You can definitely include yourself
It is right in your cited explanation of cube range:
A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
That is akin to putting yourself in the range of the spell. Even if this were not the case, you could still have the origin outside the range, and have yourself in it.
You might be able to avoid damage, if and only if you are an Evocation Wizard
Evocation wizards can sculpt spells to avoid hitting allies. However, whether you can do this is subject to interpretation:
Sculpt Spells
... that affects other creatures you can see ...
(emphasis mine)
It is up to you and your DM whether other refers to non-target creatures or not yourself, but I believe it is the former.
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
You can definitely include yourself
It is right in your cited explanation of cube range:
A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
That is akin to putting yourself in the range of the spell. Even if this were not the case, you could still have the origin outside the range, and have yourself in it.
You might be able to avoid damage, if and only if you are an Evocation Wizard
Evocation wizards can sculpt spells to avoid hitting allies. However, whether you can do this is subject to interpretation:
Sculpt Spells
... that affects other creatures you can see ...
(emphasis mine)
It is up to you and your DM whether other refers to non-target creatures or not yourself, but I believe it is the former.
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
$endgroup$
You can definitely include yourself
It is right in your cited explanation of cube range:
A cube's point of origin is not included in the cube's area of effect, unless you decide otherwise.
That is akin to putting yourself in the range of the spell. Even if this were not the case, you could still have the origin outside the range, and have yourself in it.
You might be able to avoid damage, if and only if you are an Evocation Wizard
Evocation wizards can sculpt spells to avoid hitting allies. However, whether you can do this is subject to interpretation:
Sculpt Spells
... that affects other creatures you can see ...
(emphasis mine)
It is up to you and your DM whether other refers to non-target creatures or not yourself, but I believe it is the former.
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
answered Apr 1 at 14:56
WeasemunkWeasemunk
575215
575215
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f144271%2fcan-i-cast-thunderwave-and-be-at-the-center-of-its-bottom-face-but-not-be-affec%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
$begingroup$
You should clarify whether you want to affect "adjacent" creatures that are "on the ground". The question in the title, and the bolded section, seem like a different question to the bolded section.
$endgroup$
– Andrzej Doyle
Apr 1 at 16:56
$begingroup$
@AndrzejDoyle Edited and added images for clarity
$endgroup$
– BlueMoon93
Apr 2 at 15:53