Why was the “bread communication” in the arena of Catching Fire left out in the movie? Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast? Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Favorite questions and answers from first quarter of 2019 Latest Blog Post: FanX Salt Lake Comic Convention (Spring 2019)Why was the end of Watchmen changed in the movie version?Why was a certain character in The Hunger Games killed?Did Peter Jackson ever explain why he left out the Scouring of the Shire?Why did Harry not repair his wand in the movie?Are there any differences between the Catching Fire movie and book?Why were the trackers necessary in Catching Fire?The Hunger Angst. Why the Arena tech yet the population is subjugated?Why didn't a certain character communicate more to his co-conspirators in Catching Fire?Why didn't the Tributes jump the gun in Catching Fire?Why was Gale edited out of the propos in the movie version?

How would you suggest I follow up with coworkers about our deadline that's today?

"Working on a knee"

Marquee sign letters

How to dissolve shared line segments together in QGIS?

AI positioning circles within an arc at equal distances and heights

Using NDEigensystem to solve the Mathieu equation

What do you call an IPA symbol that lacks a name (e.g. ɲ)?

What is the ongoing value of the Kanban board to the developers as opposed to management

Mechanism of the formation of peracetic acid

Has a Nobel Peace laureate ever been accused of war crimes?

Why doesn't the university give past final exams' answers?

Function on the set of limit countable ordinals

Will I lose my paid in full property

What is the numbering system used for the DSN dishes?

Capturing a lambda in another lambda can violate const qualifiers

Trigonometric and Exponential Integration

Is a self contained air-bullet cartridge feasible?

yticklabels on the right side of yaxis

Where to find documentation for `whois` command options?

Bright yellow or light yellow?

Are there existing rules/lore for MTG planeswalkers?

Using a map function on a 'Map' to change values

Co-worker works way more than he should

What to do with someone that cheated their way though university and a PhD program?



Why was the “bread communication” in the arena of Catching Fire left out in the movie?



Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast?
Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
Favorite questions and answers from first quarter of 2019
Latest Blog Post: FanX Salt Lake Comic Convention (Spring 2019)Why was the end of Watchmen changed in the movie version?Why was a certain character in The Hunger Games killed?Did Peter Jackson ever explain why he left out the Scouring of the Shire?Why did Harry not repair his wand in the movie?Are there any differences between the Catching Fire movie and book?Why were the trackers necessary in Catching Fire?The Hunger Angst. Why the Arena tech yet the population is subjugated?Why didn't a certain character communicate more to his co-conspirators in Catching Fire?Why didn't the Tributes jump the gun in Catching Fire?Why was Gale edited out of the propos in the movie version?



.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;








12















In the book, Katniss and her partners received several pieces of bread during the course of the game. The amount and type of bread serves as a countdown for a start of the rebellion.



Bread seemed so innocent, yet was used to communicate between mentor and tribute for the start of a rebellion in the 75th Hunger Games.



This was a significant detail in the book, so why did they chose to leave it out in the movie?










share|improve this question



















  • 9





    why waste time on boring moss colored bread props when u have a 130M budget and can do poisonous fog & vamp monkeys?

    – witchy
    Apr 8 at 13:40


















12















In the book, Katniss and her partners received several pieces of bread during the course of the game. The amount and type of bread serves as a countdown for a start of the rebellion.



Bread seemed so innocent, yet was used to communicate between mentor and tribute for the start of a rebellion in the 75th Hunger Games.



This was a significant detail in the book, so why did they chose to leave it out in the movie?










share|improve this question



















  • 9





    why waste time on boring moss colored bread props when u have a 130M budget and can do poisonous fog & vamp monkeys?

    – witchy
    Apr 8 at 13:40














12












12








12


1






In the book, Katniss and her partners received several pieces of bread during the course of the game. The amount and type of bread serves as a countdown for a start of the rebellion.



Bread seemed so innocent, yet was used to communicate between mentor and tribute for the start of a rebellion in the 75th Hunger Games.



This was a significant detail in the book, so why did they chose to leave it out in the movie?










share|improve this question
















In the book, Katniss and her partners received several pieces of bread during the course of the game. The amount and type of bread serves as a countdown for a start of the rebellion.



Bread seemed so innocent, yet was used to communicate between mentor and tribute for the start of a rebellion in the 75th Hunger Games.



This was a significant detail in the book, so why did they chose to leave it out in the movie?







adaptation-comparison the-hunger-games catching-fire






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Apr 8 at 14:18









Thunderforge

31.5k23150313




31.5k23150313










asked Apr 8 at 12:44









PanchoaPanchoa

7319




7319







  • 9





    why waste time on boring moss colored bread props when u have a 130M budget and can do poisonous fog & vamp monkeys?

    – witchy
    Apr 8 at 13:40













  • 9





    why waste time on boring moss colored bread props when u have a 130M budget and can do poisonous fog & vamp monkeys?

    – witchy
    Apr 8 at 13:40








9




9





why waste time on boring moss colored bread props when u have a 130M budget and can do poisonous fog & vamp monkeys?

– witchy
Apr 8 at 13:40






why waste time on boring moss colored bread props when u have a 130M budget and can do poisonous fog & vamp monkeys?

– witchy
Apr 8 at 13:40











1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















20














Books and movies are fundamentally different media, and require different storytelling techniques



Movies are better at conveying some things, like action or background events, but much worse at conveying other details, such as private character thoughts and expository details.



Also, movies have much less space for content than books do. Your average 100k word book does not fit in a 2 hour movie without significant trimming. Some things have to be cut.



The bread communication was intrinsically difficult to portray

The whole point of the bread was that the characters were not free to speak openly. That means that we would need some kind of internal monologue in order to explain the significance of the bread. An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie.



Something had to be cut for space reasons, so they chose this detail that was ill-suited for the screen as one of the cut items.






share|improve this answer




















  • 4





    "An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie." Case in point: David Lynch's Dune. There's a reason that it's so rarely done in film.

    – Thunderforge
    Apr 8 at 14:20






  • 1





    @Thunderforge Overall, this was the biggest difference between the books and the films in this case. The books spend so much time inside Katniss' head and all of that had to be left out of the movies because they didn't want use a voiceover narration. It had the unfortunate side-effect of making her performance seem a bit stiff and emotionless, but this is actually book-accurate because she had to conceal her emotions for the sake of the games. It just doesn't translate very well to film.

    – Darrel Hoffman
    Apr 8 at 15:06






  • 1





    I agree that books and movies are different, a book can exploit so much more details than a movie but in this case, if I remember well, the amount and type of bread was explained by Beetee after they got out of the arena. So that's why I wondered why they didn't translated it to the movie.

    – Panchoa
    Apr 8 at 15:19






  • 4





    @Panchoa I think that this answer is correct, but in this specific case there's also another factor. The point of the bread signals (plot-wise) is that they're extremely difficult to notice. For something to matter in a movie, it needs to be noticed by the audience (or at least be notice-able). It would be a challenge to make the bread, and its importance, clear to the audience throughout the story while also having it be subtle enough to be effective within the story. Perhaps it could be done, but it might be very challenging to do so and not worth the effort of the people making the movie.

    – Upper_Case
    Apr 8 at 17:19






  • 1





    @Upper_Case But they have a 130M budget!!! IMO they should've done it.

    – Artemis Fowl
    Apr 8 at 18:17











Your Answer








StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);

else
createEditor();

);

function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);



);













draft saved

draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f208706%2fwhy-was-the-bread-communication-in-the-arena-of-catching-fire-left-out-in-the%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









20














Books and movies are fundamentally different media, and require different storytelling techniques



Movies are better at conveying some things, like action or background events, but much worse at conveying other details, such as private character thoughts and expository details.



Also, movies have much less space for content than books do. Your average 100k word book does not fit in a 2 hour movie without significant trimming. Some things have to be cut.



The bread communication was intrinsically difficult to portray

The whole point of the bread was that the characters were not free to speak openly. That means that we would need some kind of internal monologue in order to explain the significance of the bread. An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie.



Something had to be cut for space reasons, so they chose this detail that was ill-suited for the screen as one of the cut items.






share|improve this answer




















  • 4





    "An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie." Case in point: David Lynch's Dune. There's a reason that it's so rarely done in film.

    – Thunderforge
    Apr 8 at 14:20






  • 1





    @Thunderforge Overall, this was the biggest difference between the books and the films in this case. The books spend so much time inside Katniss' head and all of that had to be left out of the movies because they didn't want use a voiceover narration. It had the unfortunate side-effect of making her performance seem a bit stiff and emotionless, but this is actually book-accurate because she had to conceal her emotions for the sake of the games. It just doesn't translate very well to film.

    – Darrel Hoffman
    Apr 8 at 15:06






  • 1





    I agree that books and movies are different, a book can exploit so much more details than a movie but in this case, if I remember well, the amount and type of bread was explained by Beetee after they got out of the arena. So that's why I wondered why they didn't translated it to the movie.

    – Panchoa
    Apr 8 at 15:19






  • 4





    @Panchoa I think that this answer is correct, but in this specific case there's also another factor. The point of the bread signals (plot-wise) is that they're extremely difficult to notice. For something to matter in a movie, it needs to be noticed by the audience (or at least be notice-able). It would be a challenge to make the bread, and its importance, clear to the audience throughout the story while also having it be subtle enough to be effective within the story. Perhaps it could be done, but it might be very challenging to do so and not worth the effort of the people making the movie.

    – Upper_Case
    Apr 8 at 17:19






  • 1





    @Upper_Case But they have a 130M budget!!! IMO they should've done it.

    – Artemis Fowl
    Apr 8 at 18:17















20














Books and movies are fundamentally different media, and require different storytelling techniques



Movies are better at conveying some things, like action or background events, but much worse at conveying other details, such as private character thoughts and expository details.



Also, movies have much less space for content than books do. Your average 100k word book does not fit in a 2 hour movie without significant trimming. Some things have to be cut.



The bread communication was intrinsically difficult to portray

The whole point of the bread was that the characters were not free to speak openly. That means that we would need some kind of internal monologue in order to explain the significance of the bread. An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie.



Something had to be cut for space reasons, so they chose this detail that was ill-suited for the screen as one of the cut items.






share|improve this answer




















  • 4





    "An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie." Case in point: David Lynch's Dune. There's a reason that it's so rarely done in film.

    – Thunderforge
    Apr 8 at 14:20






  • 1





    @Thunderforge Overall, this was the biggest difference between the books and the films in this case. The books spend so much time inside Katniss' head and all of that had to be left out of the movies because they didn't want use a voiceover narration. It had the unfortunate side-effect of making her performance seem a bit stiff and emotionless, but this is actually book-accurate because she had to conceal her emotions for the sake of the games. It just doesn't translate very well to film.

    – Darrel Hoffman
    Apr 8 at 15:06






  • 1





    I agree that books and movies are different, a book can exploit so much more details than a movie but in this case, if I remember well, the amount and type of bread was explained by Beetee after they got out of the arena. So that's why I wondered why they didn't translated it to the movie.

    – Panchoa
    Apr 8 at 15:19






  • 4





    @Panchoa I think that this answer is correct, but in this specific case there's also another factor. The point of the bread signals (plot-wise) is that they're extremely difficult to notice. For something to matter in a movie, it needs to be noticed by the audience (or at least be notice-able). It would be a challenge to make the bread, and its importance, clear to the audience throughout the story while also having it be subtle enough to be effective within the story. Perhaps it could be done, but it might be very challenging to do so and not worth the effort of the people making the movie.

    – Upper_Case
    Apr 8 at 17:19






  • 1





    @Upper_Case But they have a 130M budget!!! IMO they should've done it.

    – Artemis Fowl
    Apr 8 at 18:17













20












20








20







Books and movies are fundamentally different media, and require different storytelling techniques



Movies are better at conveying some things, like action or background events, but much worse at conveying other details, such as private character thoughts and expository details.



Also, movies have much less space for content than books do. Your average 100k word book does not fit in a 2 hour movie without significant trimming. Some things have to be cut.



The bread communication was intrinsically difficult to portray

The whole point of the bread was that the characters were not free to speak openly. That means that we would need some kind of internal monologue in order to explain the significance of the bread. An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie.



Something had to be cut for space reasons, so they chose this detail that was ill-suited for the screen as one of the cut items.






share|improve this answer















Books and movies are fundamentally different media, and require different storytelling techniques



Movies are better at conveying some things, like action or background events, but much worse at conveying other details, such as private character thoughts and expository details.



Also, movies have much less space for content than books do. Your average 100k word book does not fit in a 2 hour movie without significant trimming. Some things have to be cut.



The bread communication was intrinsically difficult to portray

The whole point of the bread was that the characters were not free to speak openly. That means that we would need some kind of internal monologue in order to explain the significance of the bread. An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie.



Something had to be cut for space reasons, so they chose this detail that was ill-suited for the screen as one of the cut items.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited Apr 8 at 20:32

























answered Apr 8 at 14:11









Arcanist LupusArcanist Lupus

2,488824




2,488824







  • 4





    "An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie." Case in point: David Lynch's Dune. There's a reason that it's so rarely done in film.

    – Thunderforge
    Apr 8 at 14:20






  • 1





    @Thunderforge Overall, this was the biggest difference between the books and the films in this case. The books spend so much time inside Katniss' head and all of that had to be left out of the movies because they didn't want use a voiceover narration. It had the unfortunate side-effect of making her performance seem a bit stiff and emotionless, but this is actually book-accurate because she had to conceal her emotions for the sake of the games. It just doesn't translate very well to film.

    – Darrel Hoffman
    Apr 8 at 15:06






  • 1





    I agree that books and movies are different, a book can exploit so much more details than a movie but in this case, if I remember well, the amount and type of bread was explained by Beetee after they got out of the arena. So that's why I wondered why they didn't translated it to the movie.

    – Panchoa
    Apr 8 at 15:19






  • 4





    @Panchoa I think that this answer is correct, but in this specific case there's also another factor. The point of the bread signals (plot-wise) is that they're extremely difficult to notice. For something to matter in a movie, it needs to be noticed by the audience (or at least be notice-able). It would be a challenge to make the bread, and its importance, clear to the audience throughout the story while also having it be subtle enough to be effective within the story. Perhaps it could be done, but it might be very challenging to do so and not worth the effort of the people making the movie.

    – Upper_Case
    Apr 8 at 17:19






  • 1





    @Upper_Case But they have a 130M budget!!! IMO they should've done it.

    – Artemis Fowl
    Apr 8 at 18:17












  • 4





    "An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie." Case in point: David Lynch's Dune. There's a reason that it's so rarely done in film.

    – Thunderforge
    Apr 8 at 14:20






  • 1





    @Thunderforge Overall, this was the biggest difference between the books and the films in this case. The books spend so much time inside Katniss' head and all of that had to be left out of the movies because they didn't want use a voiceover narration. It had the unfortunate side-effect of making her performance seem a bit stiff and emotionless, but this is actually book-accurate because she had to conceal her emotions for the sake of the games. It just doesn't translate very well to film.

    – Darrel Hoffman
    Apr 8 at 15:06






  • 1





    I agree that books and movies are different, a book can exploit so much more details than a movie but in this case, if I remember well, the amount and type of bread was explained by Beetee after they got out of the arena. So that's why I wondered why they didn't translated it to the movie.

    – Panchoa
    Apr 8 at 15:19






  • 4





    @Panchoa I think that this answer is correct, but in this specific case there's also another factor. The point of the bread signals (plot-wise) is that they're extremely difficult to notice. For something to matter in a movie, it needs to be noticed by the audience (or at least be notice-able). It would be a challenge to make the bread, and its importance, clear to the audience throughout the story while also having it be subtle enough to be effective within the story. Perhaps it could be done, but it might be very challenging to do so and not worth the effort of the people making the movie.

    – Upper_Case
    Apr 8 at 17:19






  • 1





    @Upper_Case But they have a 130M budget!!! IMO they should've done it.

    – Artemis Fowl
    Apr 8 at 18:17







4




4





"An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie." Case in point: David Lynch's Dune. There's a reason that it's so rarely done in film.

– Thunderforge
Apr 8 at 14:20





"An internal monologue or narration isn't something you can just add for one detail - you'd need to use it throughout the story, and it would significantly change the feel of the movie." Case in point: David Lynch's Dune. There's a reason that it's so rarely done in film.

– Thunderforge
Apr 8 at 14:20




1




1





@Thunderforge Overall, this was the biggest difference between the books and the films in this case. The books spend so much time inside Katniss' head and all of that had to be left out of the movies because they didn't want use a voiceover narration. It had the unfortunate side-effect of making her performance seem a bit stiff and emotionless, but this is actually book-accurate because she had to conceal her emotions for the sake of the games. It just doesn't translate very well to film.

– Darrel Hoffman
Apr 8 at 15:06





@Thunderforge Overall, this was the biggest difference between the books and the films in this case. The books spend so much time inside Katniss' head and all of that had to be left out of the movies because they didn't want use a voiceover narration. It had the unfortunate side-effect of making her performance seem a bit stiff and emotionless, but this is actually book-accurate because she had to conceal her emotions for the sake of the games. It just doesn't translate very well to film.

– Darrel Hoffman
Apr 8 at 15:06




1




1





I agree that books and movies are different, a book can exploit so much more details than a movie but in this case, if I remember well, the amount and type of bread was explained by Beetee after they got out of the arena. So that's why I wondered why they didn't translated it to the movie.

– Panchoa
Apr 8 at 15:19





I agree that books and movies are different, a book can exploit so much more details than a movie but in this case, if I remember well, the amount and type of bread was explained by Beetee after they got out of the arena. So that's why I wondered why they didn't translated it to the movie.

– Panchoa
Apr 8 at 15:19




4




4





@Panchoa I think that this answer is correct, but in this specific case there's also another factor. The point of the bread signals (plot-wise) is that they're extremely difficult to notice. For something to matter in a movie, it needs to be noticed by the audience (or at least be notice-able). It would be a challenge to make the bread, and its importance, clear to the audience throughout the story while also having it be subtle enough to be effective within the story. Perhaps it could be done, but it might be very challenging to do so and not worth the effort of the people making the movie.

– Upper_Case
Apr 8 at 17:19





@Panchoa I think that this answer is correct, but in this specific case there's also another factor. The point of the bread signals (plot-wise) is that they're extremely difficult to notice. For something to matter in a movie, it needs to be noticed by the audience (or at least be notice-able). It would be a challenge to make the bread, and its importance, clear to the audience throughout the story while also having it be subtle enough to be effective within the story. Perhaps it could be done, but it might be very challenging to do so and not worth the effort of the people making the movie.

– Upper_Case
Apr 8 at 17:19




1




1





@Upper_Case But they have a 130M budget!!! IMO they should've done it.

– Artemis Fowl
Apr 8 at 18:17





@Upper_Case But they have a 130M budget!!! IMO they should've done it.

– Artemis Fowl
Apr 8 at 18:17

















draft saved

draft discarded
















































Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!


  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid


  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f208706%2fwhy-was-the-bread-communication-in-the-arena-of-catching-fire-left-out-in-the%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

Adding axes to figuresAdding axes labels to LaTeX figuresLaTeX equivalent of ConTeXt buffersRotate a node but not its content: the case of the ellipse decorationHow to define the default vertical distance between nodes?TikZ scaling graphic and adjust node position and keep font sizeNumerical conditional within tikz keys?adding axes to shapesAlign axes across subfiguresAdding figures with a certain orderLine up nested tikz enviroments or how to get rid of themAdding axes labels to LaTeX figures

Luettelo Yhdysvaltain laivaston lentotukialuksista Lähteet | Navigointivalikko

Gary (muusikko) Sisällysluettelo Historia | Rockin' High | Lähteet | Aiheesta muualla | NavigointivalikkoInfobox OKTuomas "Gary" Keskinen Ancaran kitaristiksiProjekti Rockin' High