Paid for article while in US on F-1 visa? [closed] Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast? Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara April 2019 photo competition, “Road trip” (Read, rules are different.)Non-resident alien working for non-US company telecommuting for 10 days under ESTA Visa WaiverUK visit visa enquiriesIncome tax return filing for F1 visa?Paid hotel as condition for getting visa?How have I paid 7 lots of APD (Air Passenger Duty) for five passengers?Please check my sponsor letter for my US girlfriendCan I apply for a F1 Visa while in the U.S. on a Visa Waiver (VWP ESTA) (NO Status change in the U.S.)?Required documents for an EEA Family permit for tourismCan I work remotely for my US employer while on a Tier 4 visa in the UK?Looking for advice for my proposed spouse applying for uk visa, using visitor or tier 4 dependant?
Are `mathfont` and `mathspec` intended for same purpose?
Why aren't road bicycle wheels tiny?
What were wait-states, and why was it only an issue for PCs?
How would you suggest I follow up with coworkers about our deadline that's today?
Retract an already submitted recommendation letter (written for an undergrad student)
Finding resources for Schwäbisch?
Did war bonds have better investment alternatives during WWII?
How long can a nation maintain a technological edge over the rest of the world?
Protagonist's race is hidden - should I reveal it?
How do I check if a string is entirely made of the same substring?
Philosophers who were composers?
Is a self contained air-bullet cartridge feasible?
How to translate "red flag" into Spanish?
What's the difference between using dependency injection with a container and using a service locator?
Raising a bilingual kid. When should we introduce the majority language?
Mechanism of the formation of peracetic acid
Contradiction:Maximum Power Transfer and High resistance of load
How to keep bees out of canned beverages?
Why isn't everyone flabbergasted about Bran's "gift"?
How would it unbalance gameplay to rule that Weapon Master allows for picking a fighting style?
Are these square matrices always diagonalisable?
What is the numbering system used for the DSN dishes?
PIC mathematical operations weird problem
Does using the Inspiration rules for character defects encourage My Guy Syndrome?
Paid for article while in US on F-1 visa? [closed]
Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast?
Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
April 2019 photo competition, “Road trip” (Read, rules are different.)Non-resident alien working for non-US company telecommuting for 10 days under ESTA Visa WaiverUK visit visa enquiriesIncome tax return filing for F1 visa?Paid hotel as condition for getting visa?How have I paid 7 lots of APD (Air Passenger Duty) for five passengers?Please check my sponsor letter for my US girlfriendCan I apply for a F1 Visa while in the U.S. on a Visa Waiver (VWP ESTA) (NO Status change in the U.S.)?Required documents for an EEA Family permit for tourismCan I work remotely for my US employer while on a Tier 4 visa in the UK?Looking for advice for my proposed spouse applying for uk visa, using visitor or tier 4 dependant?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
I am an international Ph.D. student in the US and am planning to write an article for a US-based magazine. I'm doing this to increase my presence and build a relationship with this publisher. They will probably expect to pay me for this, but I am worried that this will qualify as work that is not permitted under my F-1 visa.
Ideally I would write the article and accept any payment. Does anyone know what to do in this situation? Could I have them pay me in my home country?
Please note that normally a citizen of another country can write for a newspaper or magazine in the US without either residing in or having a visa for the US. So if I were in my home country right now this would not be an issue, it is just that I am incidentally in the US that makes me concerned.
visas usa f1-visas taxes
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
closed as off-topic by Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio Apr 6 at 14:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about immigration or moving for extended periods of time (studies or employment, among others) are off-topic. Our sister site, Expatriates Stack Exchange might be a better place to ask. See also the meta post Is it OK to ask questions about immigration?." – Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio
add a comment |
I am an international Ph.D. student in the US and am planning to write an article for a US-based magazine. I'm doing this to increase my presence and build a relationship with this publisher. They will probably expect to pay me for this, but I am worried that this will qualify as work that is not permitted under my F-1 visa.
Ideally I would write the article and accept any payment. Does anyone know what to do in this situation? Could I have them pay me in my home country?
Please note that normally a citizen of another country can write for a newspaper or magazine in the US without either residing in or having a visa for the US. So if I were in my home country right now this would not be an issue, it is just that I am incidentally in the US that makes me concerned.
visas usa f1-visas taxes
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
closed as off-topic by Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio Apr 6 at 14:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about immigration or moving for extended periods of time (studies or employment, among others) are off-topic. Our sister site, Expatriates Stack Exchange might be a better place to ask. See also the meta post Is it OK to ask questions about immigration?." – Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio
5
Is selling an article to a publisher employment?
– Patricia Shanahan
Apr 5 at 14:00
Just a thought, but suppose you went to another country for a few days to actually write the article?
– DJClayworth
Apr 5 at 18:14
Just a comment that this is best asked in academia.SE as it's not strictly about travel.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 18:18
2
@RoboKaren Or, perhaps even more appropriately, expats. Long-term visa questions are generally off-topic for travel.SE.
– reirab
Apr 5 at 21:41
1
This is not an answer but just a suggestion. Every college in USA which accepts international student does have "International admission office" where there are highly knowledgeable advisors which are also in contact with DHS for any issues. I will highly recommend you to talk with them first.
– Samvid Kulkarni
Apr 5 at 23:38
add a comment |
I am an international Ph.D. student in the US and am planning to write an article for a US-based magazine. I'm doing this to increase my presence and build a relationship with this publisher. They will probably expect to pay me for this, but I am worried that this will qualify as work that is not permitted under my F-1 visa.
Ideally I would write the article and accept any payment. Does anyone know what to do in this situation? Could I have them pay me in my home country?
Please note that normally a citizen of another country can write for a newspaper or magazine in the US without either residing in or having a visa for the US. So if I were in my home country right now this would not be an issue, it is just that I am incidentally in the US that makes me concerned.
visas usa f1-visas taxes
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
I am an international Ph.D. student in the US and am planning to write an article for a US-based magazine. I'm doing this to increase my presence and build a relationship with this publisher. They will probably expect to pay me for this, but I am worried that this will qualify as work that is not permitted under my F-1 visa.
Ideally I would write the article and accept any payment. Does anyone know what to do in this situation? Could I have them pay me in my home country?
Please note that normally a citizen of another country can write for a newspaper or magazine in the US without either residing in or having a visa for the US. So if I were in my home country right now this would not be an issue, it is just that I am incidentally in the US that makes me concerned.
visas usa f1-visas taxes
visas usa f1-visas taxes
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
edited Apr 5 at 20:23
Farhan
1608
1608
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
asked Apr 5 at 5:58
user63146user63146
12315
12315
closed as off-topic by Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio Apr 6 at 14:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about immigration or moving for extended periods of time (studies or employment, among others) are off-topic. Our sister site, Expatriates Stack Exchange might be a better place to ask. See also the meta post Is it OK to ask questions about immigration?." – Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio
closed as off-topic by Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio Apr 6 at 14:56
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions about immigration or moving for extended periods of time (studies or employment, among others) are off-topic. Our sister site, Expatriates Stack Exchange might be a better place to ask. See also the meta post Is it OK to ask questions about immigration?." – Michael Hampton, David Richerby, reirab, bytebuster, Giorgio
5
Is selling an article to a publisher employment?
– Patricia Shanahan
Apr 5 at 14:00
Just a thought, but suppose you went to another country for a few days to actually write the article?
– DJClayworth
Apr 5 at 18:14
Just a comment that this is best asked in academia.SE as it's not strictly about travel.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 18:18
2
@RoboKaren Or, perhaps even more appropriately, expats. Long-term visa questions are generally off-topic for travel.SE.
– reirab
Apr 5 at 21:41
1
This is not an answer but just a suggestion. Every college in USA which accepts international student does have "International admission office" where there are highly knowledgeable advisors which are also in contact with DHS for any issues. I will highly recommend you to talk with them first.
– Samvid Kulkarni
Apr 5 at 23:38
add a comment |
5
Is selling an article to a publisher employment?
– Patricia Shanahan
Apr 5 at 14:00
Just a thought, but suppose you went to another country for a few days to actually write the article?
– DJClayworth
Apr 5 at 18:14
Just a comment that this is best asked in academia.SE as it's not strictly about travel.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 18:18
2
@RoboKaren Or, perhaps even more appropriately, expats. Long-term visa questions are generally off-topic for travel.SE.
– reirab
Apr 5 at 21:41
1
This is not an answer but just a suggestion. Every college in USA which accepts international student does have "International admission office" where there are highly knowledgeable advisors which are also in contact with DHS for any issues. I will highly recommend you to talk with them first.
– Samvid Kulkarni
Apr 5 at 23:38
5
5
Is selling an article to a publisher employment?
– Patricia Shanahan
Apr 5 at 14:00
Is selling an article to a publisher employment?
– Patricia Shanahan
Apr 5 at 14:00
Just a thought, but suppose you went to another country for a few days to actually write the article?
– DJClayworth
Apr 5 at 18:14
Just a thought, but suppose you went to another country for a few days to actually write the article?
– DJClayworth
Apr 5 at 18:14
Just a comment that this is best asked in academia.SE as it's not strictly about travel.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 18:18
Just a comment that this is best asked in academia.SE as it's not strictly about travel.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 18:18
2
2
@RoboKaren Or, perhaps even more appropriately, expats. Long-term visa questions are generally off-topic for travel.SE.
– reirab
Apr 5 at 21:41
@RoboKaren Or, perhaps even more appropriately, expats. Long-term visa questions are generally off-topic for travel.SE.
– reirab
Apr 5 at 21:41
1
1
This is not an answer but just a suggestion. Every college in USA which accepts international student does have "International admission office" where there are highly knowledgeable advisors which are also in contact with DHS for any issues. I will highly recommend you to talk with them first.
– Samvid Kulkarni
Apr 5 at 23:38
This is not an answer but just a suggestion. Every college in USA which accepts international student does have "International admission office" where there are highly knowledgeable advisors which are also in contact with DHS for any issues. I will highly recommend you to talk with them first.
– Samvid Kulkarni
Apr 5 at 23:38
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/students-and-exchange-visitors/students-and-employment
F-1 students may not work off-campus during the first academic year, but may accept on-campus employment subject to certain conditions and restrictions. After the first academic year, F-1 students may engage in three types of off-campus employment:
- Curricular Practical Training (CPT)
- Optional Practical Training (OPT) (pre-completion or post-completion)
- Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Optional Practical Training Extension (OPT)
For F-1 students any off-campus employment must be related to their area of study and must be authorized prior to starting any work by the Designated School Official (the person authorized to maintain the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS)) and USCIS.
Even though you won't have to leave the campus to write an article it will be considered "off-campus employment" when the magazine publisher is not part of your university.
So when you are still in your first year?
No go.Have you been a student for more than 1 academic year?
Then you need to request permission before writing and submitting the article.
When the magazine and/or the subject of the article are related to your field of academic study, or when you're studying journalism or similar, then you can make a case that writing such articles is practical training and you may be granted such permission.
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
3
It is "dissemination", which it is encouraged in many universities, not just for peer-reviewed papers, but also for wide public.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:15
Can they have the publisher pay the university and the university pay the author to make it an on-campus employment?
– Jungkook
Apr 5 at 12:01
5
@Jungkook Lol that's a very optimistic opinion of the university bureaucracy. Maybe if they're in a journalism department they might be able to help
– Azor Ahai
Apr 5 at 17:29
add a comment |
You can’t work as an F1 student except at your own university. The one exception is if you are on OPT.
The journal will likely want you to fill out a W9 so that they can pay you, which is when they’ll discover that you don’t have work authorization.
Alternatives to getting paid would be:
- they reimburse you for expenses (say you incurred research costs in writing the article)
- they pay your research lab at your institution or your PI (professor), again offsetting research costs
- they “pay” you in product such as giving you some of their books for free or a registration to the next conference (this is a legal grey zone, as commentators note)
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
4
Or ask your institute, and let them pay your institute. I expect you will get more by being the author of the article, then the check you will get, but you should be sure they will pay.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:13
10
Technically, paying you with products is not different from paying in cash, what is relevant is the exchange of value and not its form.
– SJuan76
Apr 5 at 9:28
3
Careful there. Payments "in kind" are still taxable under some circumstances.
– Sneftel
Apr 5 at 14:36
It's pretty common in academia and I haven't filled out W9s for when I get books instead of cash. I suppose at some time the IRS will crack down but every major publisher still seems to engage in it, so it'll be a national crackdown.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 14:37
6
@Sneftel we're more concerned here about immigration law than taxation. As far as I can tell, working for in-kind compensation would still be working for the purpose of immigration law, regardless of whether the income is taxable. The University of North Texas, at least, thinks so: "Internships and Volunteering: If you receive any compensation, even in-kind compensation including meals, housing, or insurance, USCIS considers this employment compensation. If you receive employment compensation, you must apply for CPT."
– phoog
Apr 5 at 18:08
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/students-and-exchange-visitors/students-and-employment
F-1 students may not work off-campus during the first academic year, but may accept on-campus employment subject to certain conditions and restrictions. After the first academic year, F-1 students may engage in three types of off-campus employment:
- Curricular Practical Training (CPT)
- Optional Practical Training (OPT) (pre-completion or post-completion)
- Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Optional Practical Training Extension (OPT)
For F-1 students any off-campus employment must be related to their area of study and must be authorized prior to starting any work by the Designated School Official (the person authorized to maintain the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS)) and USCIS.
Even though you won't have to leave the campus to write an article it will be considered "off-campus employment" when the magazine publisher is not part of your university.
So when you are still in your first year?
No go.Have you been a student for more than 1 academic year?
Then you need to request permission before writing and submitting the article.
When the magazine and/or the subject of the article are related to your field of academic study, or when you're studying journalism or similar, then you can make a case that writing such articles is practical training and you may be granted such permission.
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
3
It is "dissemination", which it is encouraged in many universities, not just for peer-reviewed papers, but also for wide public.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:15
Can they have the publisher pay the university and the university pay the author to make it an on-campus employment?
– Jungkook
Apr 5 at 12:01
5
@Jungkook Lol that's a very optimistic opinion of the university bureaucracy. Maybe if they're in a journalism department they might be able to help
– Azor Ahai
Apr 5 at 17:29
add a comment |
https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/students-and-exchange-visitors/students-and-employment
F-1 students may not work off-campus during the first academic year, but may accept on-campus employment subject to certain conditions and restrictions. After the first academic year, F-1 students may engage in three types of off-campus employment:
- Curricular Practical Training (CPT)
- Optional Practical Training (OPT) (pre-completion or post-completion)
- Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Optional Practical Training Extension (OPT)
For F-1 students any off-campus employment must be related to their area of study and must be authorized prior to starting any work by the Designated School Official (the person authorized to maintain the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS)) and USCIS.
Even though you won't have to leave the campus to write an article it will be considered "off-campus employment" when the magazine publisher is not part of your university.
So when you are still in your first year?
No go.Have you been a student for more than 1 academic year?
Then you need to request permission before writing and submitting the article.
When the magazine and/or the subject of the article are related to your field of academic study, or when you're studying journalism or similar, then you can make a case that writing such articles is practical training and you may be granted such permission.
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
3
It is "dissemination", which it is encouraged in many universities, not just for peer-reviewed papers, but also for wide public.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:15
Can they have the publisher pay the university and the university pay the author to make it an on-campus employment?
– Jungkook
Apr 5 at 12:01
5
@Jungkook Lol that's a very optimistic opinion of the university bureaucracy. Maybe if they're in a journalism department they might be able to help
– Azor Ahai
Apr 5 at 17:29
add a comment |
https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/students-and-exchange-visitors/students-and-employment
F-1 students may not work off-campus during the first academic year, but may accept on-campus employment subject to certain conditions and restrictions. After the first academic year, F-1 students may engage in three types of off-campus employment:
- Curricular Practical Training (CPT)
- Optional Practical Training (OPT) (pre-completion or post-completion)
- Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Optional Practical Training Extension (OPT)
For F-1 students any off-campus employment must be related to their area of study and must be authorized prior to starting any work by the Designated School Official (the person authorized to maintain the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS)) and USCIS.
Even though you won't have to leave the campus to write an article it will be considered "off-campus employment" when the magazine publisher is not part of your university.
So when you are still in your first year?
No go.Have you been a student for more than 1 academic year?
Then you need to request permission before writing and submitting the article.
When the magazine and/or the subject of the article are related to your field of academic study, or when you're studying journalism or similar, then you can make a case that writing such articles is practical training and you may be granted such permission.
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/students-and-exchange-visitors/students-and-employment
F-1 students may not work off-campus during the first academic year, but may accept on-campus employment subject to certain conditions and restrictions. After the first academic year, F-1 students may engage in three types of off-campus employment:
- Curricular Practical Training (CPT)
- Optional Practical Training (OPT) (pre-completion or post-completion)
- Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Optional Practical Training Extension (OPT)
For F-1 students any off-campus employment must be related to their area of study and must be authorized prior to starting any work by the Designated School Official (the person authorized to maintain the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS)) and USCIS.
Even though you won't have to leave the campus to write an article it will be considered "off-campus employment" when the magazine publisher is not part of your university.
So when you are still in your first year?
No go.Have you been a student for more than 1 academic year?
Then you need to request permission before writing and submitting the article.
When the magazine and/or the subject of the article are related to your field of academic study, or when you're studying journalism or similar, then you can make a case that writing such articles is practical training and you may be granted such permission.
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
edited Apr 5 at 8:36
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
answered Apr 5 at 8:12
HBruijnHBruijn
3757
3757
3
It is "dissemination", which it is encouraged in many universities, not just for peer-reviewed papers, but also for wide public.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:15
Can they have the publisher pay the university and the university pay the author to make it an on-campus employment?
– Jungkook
Apr 5 at 12:01
5
@Jungkook Lol that's a very optimistic opinion of the university bureaucracy. Maybe if they're in a journalism department they might be able to help
– Azor Ahai
Apr 5 at 17:29
add a comment |
3
It is "dissemination", which it is encouraged in many universities, not just for peer-reviewed papers, but also for wide public.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:15
Can they have the publisher pay the university and the university pay the author to make it an on-campus employment?
– Jungkook
Apr 5 at 12:01
5
@Jungkook Lol that's a very optimistic opinion of the university bureaucracy. Maybe if they're in a journalism department they might be able to help
– Azor Ahai
Apr 5 at 17:29
3
3
It is "dissemination", which it is encouraged in many universities, not just for peer-reviewed papers, but also for wide public.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:15
It is "dissemination", which it is encouraged in many universities, not just for peer-reviewed papers, but also for wide public.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:15
Can they have the publisher pay the university and the university pay the author to make it an on-campus employment?
– Jungkook
Apr 5 at 12:01
Can they have the publisher pay the university and the university pay the author to make it an on-campus employment?
– Jungkook
Apr 5 at 12:01
5
5
@Jungkook Lol that's a very optimistic opinion of the university bureaucracy. Maybe if they're in a journalism department they might be able to help
– Azor Ahai
Apr 5 at 17:29
@Jungkook Lol that's a very optimistic opinion of the university bureaucracy. Maybe if they're in a journalism department they might be able to help
– Azor Ahai
Apr 5 at 17:29
add a comment |
You can’t work as an F1 student except at your own university. The one exception is if you are on OPT.
The journal will likely want you to fill out a W9 so that they can pay you, which is when they’ll discover that you don’t have work authorization.
Alternatives to getting paid would be:
- they reimburse you for expenses (say you incurred research costs in writing the article)
- they pay your research lab at your institution or your PI (professor), again offsetting research costs
- they “pay” you in product such as giving you some of their books for free or a registration to the next conference (this is a legal grey zone, as commentators note)
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
4
Or ask your institute, and let them pay your institute. I expect you will get more by being the author of the article, then the check you will get, but you should be sure they will pay.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:13
10
Technically, paying you with products is not different from paying in cash, what is relevant is the exchange of value and not its form.
– SJuan76
Apr 5 at 9:28
3
Careful there. Payments "in kind" are still taxable under some circumstances.
– Sneftel
Apr 5 at 14:36
It's pretty common in academia and I haven't filled out W9s for when I get books instead of cash. I suppose at some time the IRS will crack down but every major publisher still seems to engage in it, so it'll be a national crackdown.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 14:37
6
@Sneftel we're more concerned here about immigration law than taxation. As far as I can tell, working for in-kind compensation would still be working for the purpose of immigration law, regardless of whether the income is taxable. The University of North Texas, at least, thinks so: "Internships and Volunteering: If you receive any compensation, even in-kind compensation including meals, housing, or insurance, USCIS considers this employment compensation. If you receive employment compensation, you must apply for CPT."
– phoog
Apr 5 at 18:08
add a comment |
You can’t work as an F1 student except at your own university. The one exception is if you are on OPT.
The journal will likely want you to fill out a W9 so that they can pay you, which is when they’ll discover that you don’t have work authorization.
Alternatives to getting paid would be:
- they reimburse you for expenses (say you incurred research costs in writing the article)
- they pay your research lab at your institution or your PI (professor), again offsetting research costs
- they “pay” you in product such as giving you some of their books for free or a registration to the next conference (this is a legal grey zone, as commentators note)
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
4
Or ask your institute, and let them pay your institute. I expect you will get more by being the author of the article, then the check you will get, but you should be sure they will pay.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:13
10
Technically, paying you with products is not different from paying in cash, what is relevant is the exchange of value and not its form.
– SJuan76
Apr 5 at 9:28
3
Careful there. Payments "in kind" are still taxable under some circumstances.
– Sneftel
Apr 5 at 14:36
It's pretty common in academia and I haven't filled out W9s for when I get books instead of cash. I suppose at some time the IRS will crack down but every major publisher still seems to engage in it, so it'll be a national crackdown.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 14:37
6
@Sneftel we're more concerned here about immigration law than taxation. As far as I can tell, working for in-kind compensation would still be working for the purpose of immigration law, regardless of whether the income is taxable. The University of North Texas, at least, thinks so: "Internships and Volunteering: If you receive any compensation, even in-kind compensation including meals, housing, or insurance, USCIS considers this employment compensation. If you receive employment compensation, you must apply for CPT."
– phoog
Apr 5 at 18:08
add a comment |
You can’t work as an F1 student except at your own university. The one exception is if you are on OPT.
The journal will likely want you to fill out a W9 so that they can pay you, which is when they’ll discover that you don’t have work authorization.
Alternatives to getting paid would be:
- they reimburse you for expenses (say you incurred research costs in writing the article)
- they pay your research lab at your institution or your PI (professor), again offsetting research costs
- they “pay” you in product such as giving you some of their books for free or a registration to the next conference (this is a legal grey zone, as commentators note)
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
You can’t work as an F1 student except at your own university. The one exception is if you are on OPT.
The journal will likely want you to fill out a W9 so that they can pay you, which is when they’ll discover that you don’t have work authorization.
Alternatives to getting paid would be:
- they reimburse you for expenses (say you incurred research costs in writing the article)
- they pay your research lab at your institution or your PI (professor), again offsetting research costs
- they “pay” you in product such as giving you some of their books for free or a registration to the next conference (this is a legal grey zone, as commentators note)
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
edited Apr 5 at 14:39
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
answered Apr 5 at 7:58
RoboKarenRoboKaren
12.9k33569
12.9k33569
4
Or ask your institute, and let them pay your institute. I expect you will get more by being the author of the article, then the check you will get, but you should be sure they will pay.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:13
10
Technically, paying you with products is not different from paying in cash, what is relevant is the exchange of value and not its form.
– SJuan76
Apr 5 at 9:28
3
Careful there. Payments "in kind" are still taxable under some circumstances.
– Sneftel
Apr 5 at 14:36
It's pretty common in academia and I haven't filled out W9s for when I get books instead of cash. I suppose at some time the IRS will crack down but every major publisher still seems to engage in it, so it'll be a national crackdown.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 14:37
6
@Sneftel we're more concerned here about immigration law than taxation. As far as I can tell, working for in-kind compensation would still be working for the purpose of immigration law, regardless of whether the income is taxable. The University of North Texas, at least, thinks so: "Internships and Volunteering: If you receive any compensation, even in-kind compensation including meals, housing, or insurance, USCIS considers this employment compensation. If you receive employment compensation, you must apply for CPT."
– phoog
Apr 5 at 18:08
add a comment |
4
Or ask your institute, and let them pay your institute. I expect you will get more by being the author of the article, then the check you will get, but you should be sure they will pay.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:13
10
Technically, paying you with products is not different from paying in cash, what is relevant is the exchange of value and not its form.
– SJuan76
Apr 5 at 9:28
3
Careful there. Payments "in kind" are still taxable under some circumstances.
– Sneftel
Apr 5 at 14:36
It's pretty common in academia and I haven't filled out W9s for when I get books instead of cash. I suppose at some time the IRS will crack down but every major publisher still seems to engage in it, so it'll be a national crackdown.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 14:37
6
@Sneftel we're more concerned here about immigration law than taxation. As far as I can tell, working for in-kind compensation would still be working for the purpose of immigration law, regardless of whether the income is taxable. The University of North Texas, at least, thinks so: "Internships and Volunteering: If you receive any compensation, even in-kind compensation including meals, housing, or insurance, USCIS considers this employment compensation. If you receive employment compensation, you must apply for CPT."
– phoog
Apr 5 at 18:08
4
4
Or ask your institute, and let them pay your institute. I expect you will get more by being the author of the article, then the check you will get, but you should be sure they will pay.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:13
Or ask your institute, and let them pay your institute. I expect you will get more by being the author of the article, then the check you will get, but you should be sure they will pay.
– Giacomo Catenazzi
Apr 5 at 8:13
10
10
Technically, paying you with products is not different from paying in cash, what is relevant is the exchange of value and not its form.
– SJuan76
Apr 5 at 9:28
Technically, paying you with products is not different from paying in cash, what is relevant is the exchange of value and not its form.
– SJuan76
Apr 5 at 9:28
3
3
Careful there. Payments "in kind" are still taxable under some circumstances.
– Sneftel
Apr 5 at 14:36
Careful there. Payments "in kind" are still taxable under some circumstances.
– Sneftel
Apr 5 at 14:36
It's pretty common in academia and I haven't filled out W9s for when I get books instead of cash. I suppose at some time the IRS will crack down but every major publisher still seems to engage in it, so it'll be a national crackdown.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 14:37
It's pretty common in academia and I haven't filled out W9s for when I get books instead of cash. I suppose at some time the IRS will crack down but every major publisher still seems to engage in it, so it'll be a national crackdown.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 14:37
6
6
@Sneftel we're more concerned here about immigration law than taxation. As far as I can tell, working for in-kind compensation would still be working for the purpose of immigration law, regardless of whether the income is taxable. The University of North Texas, at least, thinks so: "Internships and Volunteering: If you receive any compensation, even in-kind compensation including meals, housing, or insurance, USCIS considers this employment compensation. If you receive employment compensation, you must apply for CPT."
– phoog
Apr 5 at 18:08
@Sneftel we're more concerned here about immigration law than taxation. As far as I can tell, working for in-kind compensation would still be working for the purpose of immigration law, regardless of whether the income is taxable. The University of North Texas, at least, thinks so: "Internships and Volunteering: If you receive any compensation, even in-kind compensation including meals, housing, or insurance, USCIS considers this employment compensation. If you receive employment compensation, you must apply for CPT."
– phoog
Apr 5 at 18:08
add a comment |
5
Is selling an article to a publisher employment?
– Patricia Shanahan
Apr 5 at 14:00
Just a thought, but suppose you went to another country for a few days to actually write the article?
– DJClayworth
Apr 5 at 18:14
Just a comment that this is best asked in academia.SE as it's not strictly about travel.
– RoboKaren
Apr 5 at 18:18
2
@RoboKaren Or, perhaps even more appropriately, expats. Long-term visa questions are generally off-topic for travel.SE.
– reirab
Apr 5 at 21:41
1
This is not an answer but just a suggestion. Every college in USA which accepts international student does have "International admission office" where there are highly knowledgeable advisors which are also in contact with DHS for any issues. I will highly recommend you to talk with them first.
– Samvid Kulkarni
Apr 5 at 23:38