Can I use a neutral wire from another outlet to repair a broken neutral? Planned maintenance scheduled April 23, 2019 at 23:30 UTC (7:30pm US/Eastern) Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast?How can I find an open neutral?Contractor cut wire in wall - all still works fine - is this dangerous?Outlet with ground wire attached to socket ground and neutralCan I connect to a separate neutral (white) wire for my switch/outlet combination?Multiple outlets not workingHow can I provide neutral wires for my smart switches?Replacing outlet; found one white wire hot. How to connect?Mystery current on neutral wires coming into outlet boxNeutral wire going into panel has ~120 volts on itElectrical Outlet not working - Open Neutral

How do I find my Spellcasting Ability for my D&D character?

The test team as an enemy of development? And how can this be avoided?

Why not use the yoke to control yaw, as well as pitch and roll?

Marquee sign letters

Why is there so little support for joining EFTA in the British parliament?

Keep at all times, the minus sign above aligned with minus sign below

Besides transaction validation, are there any other uses of the Script language in Bitcoin

Table formatting with tabularx?

Plotting a Maclaurin series

3D Masyu - A Die

Does the main washing effect of soap come from foam?

How do Java 8 default methods hеlp with lambdas?

The Nth Gryphon Number

Why complex landing gears are used instead of simple, reliable and light weight muscle wire or shape memory alloys?

How to resize main filesystem

French equivalents of おしゃれは足元から (Every good outfit starts with the shoes)

Is the Mordenkainen's Sword spell underpowered?

Did John Wesley plagiarize Matthew Henry...?

Improvising over quartal voicings

How does the body cool itself in a stillsuit?

Is a copyright notice with a non-existent name be invalid?

Should man-made satellites feature an intelligent inverted "cow catcher"?

malloc in main() or malloc in another function: allocating memory for a struct and its members

Was the pager message from Nick Fury to Captain Marvel unnecessary?



Can I use a neutral wire from another outlet to repair a broken neutral?



Planned maintenance scheduled April 23, 2019 at 23:30 UTC (7:30pm US/Eastern)
Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast?How can I find an open neutral?Contractor cut wire in wall - all still works fine - is this dangerous?Outlet with ground wire attached to socket ground and neutralCan I connect to a separate neutral (white) wire for my switch/outlet combination?Multiple outlets not workingHow can I provide neutral wires for my smart switches?Replacing outlet; found one white wire hot. How to connect?Mystery current on neutral wires coming into outlet boxNeutral wire going into panel has ~120 volts on itElectrical Outlet not working - Open Neutral



.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;








12















Recently one wall of outlets quit working. Testing shows the hots are all good and the grounds are all good but the neutrals are all dead. They are all connected to each other but somewhere have lost the connection to the panel.



Can I add a neutral from another nearby outlet which will make these outlets work without tearing up the walls to find where the neutral has become disconnected?










share|improve this question






























    12















    Recently one wall of outlets quit working. Testing shows the hots are all good and the grounds are all good but the neutrals are all dead. They are all connected to each other but somewhere have lost the connection to the panel.



    Can I add a neutral from another nearby outlet which will make these outlets work without tearing up the walls to find where the neutral has become disconnected?










    share|improve this question


























      12












      12








      12








      Recently one wall of outlets quit working. Testing shows the hots are all good and the grounds are all good but the neutrals are all dead. They are all connected to each other but somewhere have lost the connection to the panel.



      Can I add a neutral from another nearby outlet which will make these outlets work without tearing up the walls to find where the neutral has become disconnected?










      share|improve this question
















      Recently one wall of outlets quit working. Testing shows the hots are all good and the grounds are all good but the neutrals are all dead. They are all connected to each other but somewhere have lost the connection to the panel.



      Can I add a neutral from another nearby outlet which will make these outlets work without tearing up the walls to find where the neutral has become disconnected?







      electrical wiring neutral






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited Apr 4 at 13:13









      Machavity

      8,50821942




      8,50821942










      asked Apr 3 at 17:26









      James WolfJames Wolf

      613




      613




















          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          21














          No, you cannot do this. Assuming the nearby outlet you want to borrow neutral from is on a different circuit, you will be overloading its neutral. Even if it is the same circuit, it's very bad practice to leave broken wiring energized without fixing it -- what if it moves a little and reconnects just enough to arc? Then your house is on fire.



          However, fixing this properly probably isn't as much work as you think. You most likely will not need to tear up your walls. Unless you recently drove a nail through a wire, the wire inside the walls usually doesn't just break. Rather, things usually go wrong at the outlets themselves. The so-called "backstab" outlets are especially prone to having the wires come loose over time. So the fix for this will involve pulling out each outlet in turn, making sure all screws, wirenuts, etc are tight, and ideally replacing any backstabs in the circuit. Most likely you'll find one of the outlets had the white wire come loose, and when you tighten it, everything starts working again.






          share|improve this answer




















          • 8





            The failure is usually at the last working outlet or the first non working outlet. In rare cases where nothing on the circuit works it can be in the panel.

            – Ed Beal
            Apr 3 at 18:44











          • If a breaker was tripping you might think about damage to the wire between boxes more (drove a nail into a wire, etc) but it would be hard for wire damage to result in only a broken neutral. Find all the outlets that do work and start checking them starting with the closest one to the broken outlet.

            – JPhi1618
            Apr 3 at 19:01






          • 3





            That's true; most likely OP can get away with only checking only two outlets IF they know what order the circuit is wired in. However, I still recommend opening them all up since most likely they were all wired at the same time with the same techniques, and if one failed, the others might not be far behind. And that way you don't need to know the circuit order, which most likely OP doesn't.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 19:55






          • 2





            "wires come lose" should be "wires come loose" (not enough characters to edit)

            – Kat
            Apr 4 at 8:00











          • @EdBeal The 'nearby' outlet seems like a likely candidate.

            – JimmyJames
            Apr 4 at 20:37


















          15














          Absolutely not. That sort of thinking works with safety ground, which does not ever carry current, except during a fault condition (and we hope there aren't 2 independent fault conditions occurring at once).



          However, current flows in loops. Neutral is the normal "return half" of the loop, and it needs to be dedicated to this circuit. In fact, neutrals don't have fuses and rely on the circuit breaker on the hot side to protect the neutral. You can't have two circuits sharing a neutral, or you get this!



          enter image description here




          But there's another problem. This is AC power. It reverses polarity 100/120 times a second, which throws electro-magnetic force into everything around the wires. That's why transformers work. To keep that from causing a lot of problems, we require that all the current that goes out one wire comes back on another in the same cable or conduit. Among the wires, currents are equal and opposite, so their electro-magnetic forces cancel each other out.



          Now, borrowing a neutral means current is now making a big loop - "out" (really, it's AC) this circuit's "hot" wire and returning via another circuit's "neutral" wire. That will throw EMF on both circuits, causing all sorts of mischief - eddy current heating, wire vibration leading to noise and metal fatigue leading to cracking and spot heating, etc. Nope.



          Because of this, all practical wiring is done on a physical "tree" topology -- a branch may "split", but it may never "loop back" onto itself or another branch (except in one particular way, and even then, only in the UK where this is officially sanctioned).




          Now, it can be hard to see when you're not practiced in a field. But this is most likely an easy problem. Wire breaks inside walls are rare. Wire problems are almost always at terminations of the cable run... And by definition, this must occur at either the last working outlet or the first failed outlet in the sequence.



          As Nate discusses in his answer, backstab connections are the usual culprit. You're best changing it to a screw connection, but current Code advises using an $80 torque screwdriver, because "too loose" is more of a problem than "too tight".



          If it's at the service panel, the neutral may go to a neutral bar, or a GFCI or AFCI breaker. Torque matters here too.



          Lastly, if this diagnosis is given you by a 3-light tester, know that some of us call it a "Magic 8-ball" tester. It is made as a pass-fail device for new wiring e.g. During new construction. When troubleshooting old existing work, the legends can be wrong to the point of whimsical. The lights are useful; they save you the trouble of making 3 measurements with a neon tester.






          share|improve this answer

























          • Excellent answer as always. The only small quibble is that the cost of torque screwdrivers has come down significantly recently, and decent ones can now be had for ~$45. Though for regular outlets with Cu wire, I feel like "as tight as you can get it" with a regular screwdriver is fine -- it's probably a bit more torque than spec but the screw head will usually strip out long before the wire gets damaged.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 23:37











          • Another point I didn't see mentioned is if you bridge your neutral to another circuit derived from another phase of the mains in a multi-phase installation, the outlets will get a lot more than 120v!

            – Drunken Code Monkey
            Apr 4 at 2:57











          • @DrunkenCodeMonkey Oh, so true. I have an old factory with two 120/240 transformers and main panels right next to each other. I noticed the two had been initially setup to grab different 480 phases, but were moved to the same phase. As I got into the 120 wiring, I discovered the neutrals were crisscrossed in several places. Some circuits even grabbed any convenient neutral, even out of the wrong panel. SMH...

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 3:58












          • Good answer. "Neutrals don't have fuses" is however not necessarily true. This depends on your local code. In general, just wanted to point out that the person asking (or other readers) might be from different countries with different regulations.

            – istepaniuk
            Apr 4 at 10:43











          • @istepaniuk I would be keenly interested in hearing about any country that fuses neutrals as a contemporary practice. Other than the Phillippines... There are good reasons to not fuse neutral.

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 14:57











          Your Answer








          StackExchange.ready(function()
          var channelOptions =
          tags: "".split(" "),
          id: "73"
          ;
          initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
          // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
          if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
          createEditor();
          );

          else
          createEditor();

          );

          function createEditor()
          StackExchange.prepareEditor(
          heartbeatType: 'answer',
          autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
          convertImagesToLinks: false,
          noModals: true,
          showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
          reputationToPostImages: null,
          bindNavPrevention: true,
          postfix: "",
          imageUploader:
          brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
          contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
          allowUrls: true
          ,
          noCode: true, onDemand: true,
          discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
          ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
          );



          );













          draft saved

          draft discarded


















          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fdiy.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f161304%2fcan-i-use-a-neutral-wire-from-another-outlet-to-repair-a-broken-neutral%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown

























          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes








          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes









          21














          No, you cannot do this. Assuming the nearby outlet you want to borrow neutral from is on a different circuit, you will be overloading its neutral. Even if it is the same circuit, it's very bad practice to leave broken wiring energized without fixing it -- what if it moves a little and reconnects just enough to arc? Then your house is on fire.



          However, fixing this properly probably isn't as much work as you think. You most likely will not need to tear up your walls. Unless you recently drove a nail through a wire, the wire inside the walls usually doesn't just break. Rather, things usually go wrong at the outlets themselves. The so-called "backstab" outlets are especially prone to having the wires come loose over time. So the fix for this will involve pulling out each outlet in turn, making sure all screws, wirenuts, etc are tight, and ideally replacing any backstabs in the circuit. Most likely you'll find one of the outlets had the white wire come loose, and when you tighten it, everything starts working again.






          share|improve this answer




















          • 8





            The failure is usually at the last working outlet or the first non working outlet. In rare cases where nothing on the circuit works it can be in the panel.

            – Ed Beal
            Apr 3 at 18:44











          • If a breaker was tripping you might think about damage to the wire between boxes more (drove a nail into a wire, etc) but it would be hard for wire damage to result in only a broken neutral. Find all the outlets that do work and start checking them starting with the closest one to the broken outlet.

            – JPhi1618
            Apr 3 at 19:01






          • 3





            That's true; most likely OP can get away with only checking only two outlets IF they know what order the circuit is wired in. However, I still recommend opening them all up since most likely they were all wired at the same time with the same techniques, and if one failed, the others might not be far behind. And that way you don't need to know the circuit order, which most likely OP doesn't.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 19:55






          • 2





            "wires come lose" should be "wires come loose" (not enough characters to edit)

            – Kat
            Apr 4 at 8:00











          • @EdBeal The 'nearby' outlet seems like a likely candidate.

            – JimmyJames
            Apr 4 at 20:37















          21














          No, you cannot do this. Assuming the nearby outlet you want to borrow neutral from is on a different circuit, you will be overloading its neutral. Even if it is the same circuit, it's very bad practice to leave broken wiring energized without fixing it -- what if it moves a little and reconnects just enough to arc? Then your house is on fire.



          However, fixing this properly probably isn't as much work as you think. You most likely will not need to tear up your walls. Unless you recently drove a nail through a wire, the wire inside the walls usually doesn't just break. Rather, things usually go wrong at the outlets themselves. The so-called "backstab" outlets are especially prone to having the wires come loose over time. So the fix for this will involve pulling out each outlet in turn, making sure all screws, wirenuts, etc are tight, and ideally replacing any backstabs in the circuit. Most likely you'll find one of the outlets had the white wire come loose, and when you tighten it, everything starts working again.






          share|improve this answer




















          • 8





            The failure is usually at the last working outlet or the first non working outlet. In rare cases where nothing on the circuit works it can be in the panel.

            – Ed Beal
            Apr 3 at 18:44











          • If a breaker was tripping you might think about damage to the wire between boxes more (drove a nail into a wire, etc) but it would be hard for wire damage to result in only a broken neutral. Find all the outlets that do work and start checking them starting with the closest one to the broken outlet.

            – JPhi1618
            Apr 3 at 19:01






          • 3





            That's true; most likely OP can get away with only checking only two outlets IF they know what order the circuit is wired in. However, I still recommend opening them all up since most likely they were all wired at the same time with the same techniques, and if one failed, the others might not be far behind. And that way you don't need to know the circuit order, which most likely OP doesn't.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 19:55






          • 2





            "wires come lose" should be "wires come loose" (not enough characters to edit)

            – Kat
            Apr 4 at 8:00











          • @EdBeal The 'nearby' outlet seems like a likely candidate.

            – JimmyJames
            Apr 4 at 20:37













          21












          21








          21







          No, you cannot do this. Assuming the nearby outlet you want to borrow neutral from is on a different circuit, you will be overloading its neutral. Even if it is the same circuit, it's very bad practice to leave broken wiring energized without fixing it -- what if it moves a little and reconnects just enough to arc? Then your house is on fire.



          However, fixing this properly probably isn't as much work as you think. You most likely will not need to tear up your walls. Unless you recently drove a nail through a wire, the wire inside the walls usually doesn't just break. Rather, things usually go wrong at the outlets themselves. The so-called "backstab" outlets are especially prone to having the wires come loose over time. So the fix for this will involve pulling out each outlet in turn, making sure all screws, wirenuts, etc are tight, and ideally replacing any backstabs in the circuit. Most likely you'll find one of the outlets had the white wire come loose, and when you tighten it, everything starts working again.






          share|improve this answer















          No, you cannot do this. Assuming the nearby outlet you want to borrow neutral from is on a different circuit, you will be overloading its neutral. Even if it is the same circuit, it's very bad practice to leave broken wiring energized without fixing it -- what if it moves a little and reconnects just enough to arc? Then your house is on fire.



          However, fixing this properly probably isn't as much work as you think. You most likely will not need to tear up your walls. Unless you recently drove a nail through a wire, the wire inside the walls usually doesn't just break. Rather, things usually go wrong at the outlets themselves. The so-called "backstab" outlets are especially prone to having the wires come loose over time. So the fix for this will involve pulling out each outlet in turn, making sure all screws, wirenuts, etc are tight, and ideally replacing any backstabs in the circuit. Most likely you'll find one of the outlets had the white wire come loose, and when you tighten it, everything starts working again.







          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited Apr 4 at 16:09









          Community

          1




          1










          answered Apr 3 at 17:49









          Nate StricklandNate Strickland

          4369




          4369







          • 8





            The failure is usually at the last working outlet or the first non working outlet. In rare cases where nothing on the circuit works it can be in the panel.

            – Ed Beal
            Apr 3 at 18:44











          • If a breaker was tripping you might think about damage to the wire between boxes more (drove a nail into a wire, etc) but it would be hard for wire damage to result in only a broken neutral. Find all the outlets that do work and start checking them starting with the closest one to the broken outlet.

            – JPhi1618
            Apr 3 at 19:01






          • 3





            That's true; most likely OP can get away with only checking only two outlets IF they know what order the circuit is wired in. However, I still recommend opening them all up since most likely they were all wired at the same time with the same techniques, and if one failed, the others might not be far behind. And that way you don't need to know the circuit order, which most likely OP doesn't.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 19:55






          • 2





            "wires come lose" should be "wires come loose" (not enough characters to edit)

            – Kat
            Apr 4 at 8:00











          • @EdBeal The 'nearby' outlet seems like a likely candidate.

            – JimmyJames
            Apr 4 at 20:37












          • 8





            The failure is usually at the last working outlet or the first non working outlet. In rare cases where nothing on the circuit works it can be in the panel.

            – Ed Beal
            Apr 3 at 18:44











          • If a breaker was tripping you might think about damage to the wire between boxes more (drove a nail into a wire, etc) but it would be hard for wire damage to result in only a broken neutral. Find all the outlets that do work and start checking them starting with the closest one to the broken outlet.

            – JPhi1618
            Apr 3 at 19:01






          • 3





            That's true; most likely OP can get away with only checking only two outlets IF they know what order the circuit is wired in. However, I still recommend opening them all up since most likely they were all wired at the same time with the same techniques, and if one failed, the others might not be far behind. And that way you don't need to know the circuit order, which most likely OP doesn't.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 19:55






          • 2





            "wires come lose" should be "wires come loose" (not enough characters to edit)

            – Kat
            Apr 4 at 8:00











          • @EdBeal The 'nearby' outlet seems like a likely candidate.

            – JimmyJames
            Apr 4 at 20:37







          8




          8





          The failure is usually at the last working outlet or the first non working outlet. In rare cases where nothing on the circuit works it can be in the panel.

          – Ed Beal
          Apr 3 at 18:44





          The failure is usually at the last working outlet or the first non working outlet. In rare cases where nothing on the circuit works it can be in the panel.

          – Ed Beal
          Apr 3 at 18:44













          If a breaker was tripping you might think about damage to the wire between boxes more (drove a nail into a wire, etc) but it would be hard for wire damage to result in only a broken neutral. Find all the outlets that do work and start checking them starting with the closest one to the broken outlet.

          – JPhi1618
          Apr 3 at 19:01





          If a breaker was tripping you might think about damage to the wire between boxes more (drove a nail into a wire, etc) but it would be hard for wire damage to result in only a broken neutral. Find all the outlets that do work and start checking them starting with the closest one to the broken outlet.

          – JPhi1618
          Apr 3 at 19:01




          3




          3





          That's true; most likely OP can get away with only checking only two outlets IF they know what order the circuit is wired in. However, I still recommend opening them all up since most likely they were all wired at the same time with the same techniques, and if one failed, the others might not be far behind. And that way you don't need to know the circuit order, which most likely OP doesn't.

          – Nate Strickland
          Apr 3 at 19:55





          That's true; most likely OP can get away with only checking only two outlets IF they know what order the circuit is wired in. However, I still recommend opening them all up since most likely they were all wired at the same time with the same techniques, and if one failed, the others might not be far behind. And that way you don't need to know the circuit order, which most likely OP doesn't.

          – Nate Strickland
          Apr 3 at 19:55




          2




          2





          "wires come lose" should be "wires come loose" (not enough characters to edit)

          – Kat
          Apr 4 at 8:00





          "wires come lose" should be "wires come loose" (not enough characters to edit)

          – Kat
          Apr 4 at 8:00













          @EdBeal The 'nearby' outlet seems like a likely candidate.

          – JimmyJames
          Apr 4 at 20:37





          @EdBeal The 'nearby' outlet seems like a likely candidate.

          – JimmyJames
          Apr 4 at 20:37













          15














          Absolutely not. That sort of thinking works with safety ground, which does not ever carry current, except during a fault condition (and we hope there aren't 2 independent fault conditions occurring at once).



          However, current flows in loops. Neutral is the normal "return half" of the loop, and it needs to be dedicated to this circuit. In fact, neutrals don't have fuses and rely on the circuit breaker on the hot side to protect the neutral. You can't have two circuits sharing a neutral, or you get this!



          enter image description here




          But there's another problem. This is AC power. It reverses polarity 100/120 times a second, which throws electro-magnetic force into everything around the wires. That's why transformers work. To keep that from causing a lot of problems, we require that all the current that goes out one wire comes back on another in the same cable or conduit. Among the wires, currents are equal and opposite, so their electro-magnetic forces cancel each other out.



          Now, borrowing a neutral means current is now making a big loop - "out" (really, it's AC) this circuit's "hot" wire and returning via another circuit's "neutral" wire. That will throw EMF on both circuits, causing all sorts of mischief - eddy current heating, wire vibration leading to noise and metal fatigue leading to cracking and spot heating, etc. Nope.



          Because of this, all practical wiring is done on a physical "tree" topology -- a branch may "split", but it may never "loop back" onto itself or another branch (except in one particular way, and even then, only in the UK where this is officially sanctioned).




          Now, it can be hard to see when you're not practiced in a field. But this is most likely an easy problem. Wire breaks inside walls are rare. Wire problems are almost always at terminations of the cable run... And by definition, this must occur at either the last working outlet or the first failed outlet in the sequence.



          As Nate discusses in his answer, backstab connections are the usual culprit. You're best changing it to a screw connection, but current Code advises using an $80 torque screwdriver, because "too loose" is more of a problem than "too tight".



          If it's at the service panel, the neutral may go to a neutral bar, or a GFCI or AFCI breaker. Torque matters here too.



          Lastly, if this diagnosis is given you by a 3-light tester, know that some of us call it a "Magic 8-ball" tester. It is made as a pass-fail device for new wiring e.g. During new construction. When troubleshooting old existing work, the legends can be wrong to the point of whimsical. The lights are useful; they save you the trouble of making 3 measurements with a neon tester.






          share|improve this answer

























          • Excellent answer as always. The only small quibble is that the cost of torque screwdrivers has come down significantly recently, and decent ones can now be had for ~$45. Though for regular outlets with Cu wire, I feel like "as tight as you can get it" with a regular screwdriver is fine -- it's probably a bit more torque than spec but the screw head will usually strip out long before the wire gets damaged.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 23:37











          • Another point I didn't see mentioned is if you bridge your neutral to another circuit derived from another phase of the mains in a multi-phase installation, the outlets will get a lot more than 120v!

            – Drunken Code Monkey
            Apr 4 at 2:57











          • @DrunkenCodeMonkey Oh, so true. I have an old factory with two 120/240 transformers and main panels right next to each other. I noticed the two had been initially setup to grab different 480 phases, but were moved to the same phase. As I got into the 120 wiring, I discovered the neutrals were crisscrossed in several places. Some circuits even grabbed any convenient neutral, even out of the wrong panel. SMH...

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 3:58












          • Good answer. "Neutrals don't have fuses" is however not necessarily true. This depends on your local code. In general, just wanted to point out that the person asking (or other readers) might be from different countries with different regulations.

            – istepaniuk
            Apr 4 at 10:43











          • @istepaniuk I would be keenly interested in hearing about any country that fuses neutrals as a contemporary practice. Other than the Phillippines... There are good reasons to not fuse neutral.

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 14:57















          15














          Absolutely not. That sort of thinking works with safety ground, which does not ever carry current, except during a fault condition (and we hope there aren't 2 independent fault conditions occurring at once).



          However, current flows in loops. Neutral is the normal "return half" of the loop, and it needs to be dedicated to this circuit. In fact, neutrals don't have fuses and rely on the circuit breaker on the hot side to protect the neutral. You can't have two circuits sharing a neutral, or you get this!



          enter image description here




          But there's another problem. This is AC power. It reverses polarity 100/120 times a second, which throws electro-magnetic force into everything around the wires. That's why transformers work. To keep that from causing a lot of problems, we require that all the current that goes out one wire comes back on another in the same cable or conduit. Among the wires, currents are equal and opposite, so their electro-magnetic forces cancel each other out.



          Now, borrowing a neutral means current is now making a big loop - "out" (really, it's AC) this circuit's "hot" wire and returning via another circuit's "neutral" wire. That will throw EMF on both circuits, causing all sorts of mischief - eddy current heating, wire vibration leading to noise and metal fatigue leading to cracking and spot heating, etc. Nope.



          Because of this, all practical wiring is done on a physical "tree" topology -- a branch may "split", but it may never "loop back" onto itself or another branch (except in one particular way, and even then, only in the UK where this is officially sanctioned).




          Now, it can be hard to see when you're not practiced in a field. But this is most likely an easy problem. Wire breaks inside walls are rare. Wire problems are almost always at terminations of the cable run... And by definition, this must occur at either the last working outlet or the first failed outlet in the sequence.



          As Nate discusses in his answer, backstab connections are the usual culprit. You're best changing it to a screw connection, but current Code advises using an $80 torque screwdriver, because "too loose" is more of a problem than "too tight".



          If it's at the service panel, the neutral may go to a neutral bar, or a GFCI or AFCI breaker. Torque matters here too.



          Lastly, if this diagnosis is given you by a 3-light tester, know that some of us call it a "Magic 8-ball" tester. It is made as a pass-fail device for new wiring e.g. During new construction. When troubleshooting old existing work, the legends can be wrong to the point of whimsical. The lights are useful; they save you the trouble of making 3 measurements with a neon tester.






          share|improve this answer

























          • Excellent answer as always. The only small quibble is that the cost of torque screwdrivers has come down significantly recently, and decent ones can now be had for ~$45. Though for regular outlets with Cu wire, I feel like "as tight as you can get it" with a regular screwdriver is fine -- it's probably a bit more torque than spec but the screw head will usually strip out long before the wire gets damaged.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 23:37











          • Another point I didn't see mentioned is if you bridge your neutral to another circuit derived from another phase of the mains in a multi-phase installation, the outlets will get a lot more than 120v!

            – Drunken Code Monkey
            Apr 4 at 2:57











          • @DrunkenCodeMonkey Oh, so true. I have an old factory with two 120/240 transformers and main panels right next to each other. I noticed the two had been initially setup to grab different 480 phases, but were moved to the same phase. As I got into the 120 wiring, I discovered the neutrals were crisscrossed in several places. Some circuits even grabbed any convenient neutral, even out of the wrong panel. SMH...

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 3:58












          • Good answer. "Neutrals don't have fuses" is however not necessarily true. This depends on your local code. In general, just wanted to point out that the person asking (or other readers) might be from different countries with different regulations.

            – istepaniuk
            Apr 4 at 10:43











          • @istepaniuk I would be keenly interested in hearing about any country that fuses neutrals as a contemporary practice. Other than the Phillippines... There are good reasons to not fuse neutral.

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 14:57













          15












          15








          15







          Absolutely not. That sort of thinking works with safety ground, which does not ever carry current, except during a fault condition (and we hope there aren't 2 independent fault conditions occurring at once).



          However, current flows in loops. Neutral is the normal "return half" of the loop, and it needs to be dedicated to this circuit. In fact, neutrals don't have fuses and rely on the circuit breaker on the hot side to protect the neutral. You can't have two circuits sharing a neutral, or you get this!



          enter image description here




          But there's another problem. This is AC power. It reverses polarity 100/120 times a second, which throws electro-magnetic force into everything around the wires. That's why transformers work. To keep that from causing a lot of problems, we require that all the current that goes out one wire comes back on another in the same cable or conduit. Among the wires, currents are equal and opposite, so their electro-magnetic forces cancel each other out.



          Now, borrowing a neutral means current is now making a big loop - "out" (really, it's AC) this circuit's "hot" wire and returning via another circuit's "neutral" wire. That will throw EMF on both circuits, causing all sorts of mischief - eddy current heating, wire vibration leading to noise and metal fatigue leading to cracking and spot heating, etc. Nope.



          Because of this, all practical wiring is done on a physical "tree" topology -- a branch may "split", but it may never "loop back" onto itself or another branch (except in one particular way, and even then, only in the UK where this is officially sanctioned).




          Now, it can be hard to see when you're not practiced in a field. But this is most likely an easy problem. Wire breaks inside walls are rare. Wire problems are almost always at terminations of the cable run... And by definition, this must occur at either the last working outlet or the first failed outlet in the sequence.



          As Nate discusses in his answer, backstab connections are the usual culprit. You're best changing it to a screw connection, but current Code advises using an $80 torque screwdriver, because "too loose" is more of a problem than "too tight".



          If it's at the service panel, the neutral may go to a neutral bar, or a GFCI or AFCI breaker. Torque matters here too.



          Lastly, if this diagnosis is given you by a 3-light tester, know that some of us call it a "Magic 8-ball" tester. It is made as a pass-fail device for new wiring e.g. During new construction. When troubleshooting old existing work, the legends can be wrong to the point of whimsical. The lights are useful; they save you the trouble of making 3 measurements with a neon tester.






          share|improve this answer















          Absolutely not. That sort of thinking works with safety ground, which does not ever carry current, except during a fault condition (and we hope there aren't 2 independent fault conditions occurring at once).



          However, current flows in loops. Neutral is the normal "return half" of the loop, and it needs to be dedicated to this circuit. In fact, neutrals don't have fuses and rely on the circuit breaker on the hot side to protect the neutral. You can't have two circuits sharing a neutral, or you get this!



          enter image description here




          But there's another problem. This is AC power. It reverses polarity 100/120 times a second, which throws electro-magnetic force into everything around the wires. That's why transformers work. To keep that from causing a lot of problems, we require that all the current that goes out one wire comes back on another in the same cable or conduit. Among the wires, currents are equal and opposite, so their electro-magnetic forces cancel each other out.



          Now, borrowing a neutral means current is now making a big loop - "out" (really, it's AC) this circuit's "hot" wire and returning via another circuit's "neutral" wire. That will throw EMF on both circuits, causing all sorts of mischief - eddy current heating, wire vibration leading to noise and metal fatigue leading to cracking and spot heating, etc. Nope.



          Because of this, all practical wiring is done on a physical "tree" topology -- a branch may "split", but it may never "loop back" onto itself or another branch (except in one particular way, and even then, only in the UK where this is officially sanctioned).




          Now, it can be hard to see when you're not practiced in a field. But this is most likely an easy problem. Wire breaks inside walls are rare. Wire problems are almost always at terminations of the cable run... And by definition, this must occur at either the last working outlet or the first failed outlet in the sequence.



          As Nate discusses in his answer, backstab connections are the usual culprit. You're best changing it to a screw connection, but current Code advises using an $80 torque screwdriver, because "too loose" is more of a problem than "too tight".



          If it's at the service panel, the neutral may go to a neutral bar, or a GFCI or AFCI breaker. Torque matters here too.



          Lastly, if this diagnosis is given you by a 3-light tester, know that some of us call it a "Magic 8-ball" tester. It is made as a pass-fail device for new wiring e.g. During new construction. When troubleshooting old existing work, the legends can be wrong to the point of whimsical. The lights are useful; they save you the trouble of making 3 measurements with a neon tester.







          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited Apr 3 at 21:18

























          answered Apr 3 at 21:09









          HarperHarper

          76.9k449153




          76.9k449153












          • Excellent answer as always. The only small quibble is that the cost of torque screwdrivers has come down significantly recently, and decent ones can now be had for ~$45. Though for regular outlets with Cu wire, I feel like "as tight as you can get it" with a regular screwdriver is fine -- it's probably a bit more torque than spec but the screw head will usually strip out long before the wire gets damaged.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 23:37











          • Another point I didn't see mentioned is if you bridge your neutral to another circuit derived from another phase of the mains in a multi-phase installation, the outlets will get a lot more than 120v!

            – Drunken Code Monkey
            Apr 4 at 2:57











          • @DrunkenCodeMonkey Oh, so true. I have an old factory with two 120/240 transformers and main panels right next to each other. I noticed the two had been initially setup to grab different 480 phases, but were moved to the same phase. As I got into the 120 wiring, I discovered the neutrals were crisscrossed in several places. Some circuits even grabbed any convenient neutral, even out of the wrong panel. SMH...

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 3:58












          • Good answer. "Neutrals don't have fuses" is however not necessarily true. This depends on your local code. In general, just wanted to point out that the person asking (or other readers) might be from different countries with different regulations.

            – istepaniuk
            Apr 4 at 10:43











          • @istepaniuk I would be keenly interested in hearing about any country that fuses neutrals as a contemporary practice. Other than the Phillippines... There are good reasons to not fuse neutral.

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 14:57

















          • Excellent answer as always. The only small quibble is that the cost of torque screwdrivers has come down significantly recently, and decent ones can now be had for ~$45. Though for regular outlets with Cu wire, I feel like "as tight as you can get it" with a regular screwdriver is fine -- it's probably a bit more torque than spec but the screw head will usually strip out long before the wire gets damaged.

            – Nate Strickland
            Apr 3 at 23:37











          • Another point I didn't see mentioned is if you bridge your neutral to another circuit derived from another phase of the mains in a multi-phase installation, the outlets will get a lot more than 120v!

            – Drunken Code Monkey
            Apr 4 at 2:57











          • @DrunkenCodeMonkey Oh, so true. I have an old factory with two 120/240 transformers and main panels right next to each other. I noticed the two had been initially setup to grab different 480 phases, but were moved to the same phase. As I got into the 120 wiring, I discovered the neutrals were crisscrossed in several places. Some circuits even grabbed any convenient neutral, even out of the wrong panel. SMH...

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 3:58












          • Good answer. "Neutrals don't have fuses" is however not necessarily true. This depends on your local code. In general, just wanted to point out that the person asking (or other readers) might be from different countries with different regulations.

            – istepaniuk
            Apr 4 at 10:43











          • @istepaniuk I would be keenly interested in hearing about any country that fuses neutrals as a contemporary practice. Other than the Phillippines... There are good reasons to not fuse neutral.

            – Harper
            Apr 4 at 14:57
















          Excellent answer as always. The only small quibble is that the cost of torque screwdrivers has come down significantly recently, and decent ones can now be had for ~$45. Though for regular outlets with Cu wire, I feel like "as tight as you can get it" with a regular screwdriver is fine -- it's probably a bit more torque than spec but the screw head will usually strip out long before the wire gets damaged.

          – Nate Strickland
          Apr 3 at 23:37





          Excellent answer as always. The only small quibble is that the cost of torque screwdrivers has come down significantly recently, and decent ones can now be had for ~$45. Though for regular outlets with Cu wire, I feel like "as tight as you can get it" with a regular screwdriver is fine -- it's probably a bit more torque than spec but the screw head will usually strip out long before the wire gets damaged.

          – Nate Strickland
          Apr 3 at 23:37













          Another point I didn't see mentioned is if you bridge your neutral to another circuit derived from another phase of the mains in a multi-phase installation, the outlets will get a lot more than 120v!

          – Drunken Code Monkey
          Apr 4 at 2:57





          Another point I didn't see mentioned is if you bridge your neutral to another circuit derived from another phase of the mains in a multi-phase installation, the outlets will get a lot more than 120v!

          – Drunken Code Monkey
          Apr 4 at 2:57













          @DrunkenCodeMonkey Oh, so true. I have an old factory with two 120/240 transformers and main panels right next to each other. I noticed the two had been initially setup to grab different 480 phases, but were moved to the same phase. As I got into the 120 wiring, I discovered the neutrals were crisscrossed in several places. Some circuits even grabbed any convenient neutral, even out of the wrong panel. SMH...

          – Harper
          Apr 4 at 3:58






          @DrunkenCodeMonkey Oh, so true. I have an old factory with two 120/240 transformers and main panels right next to each other. I noticed the two had been initially setup to grab different 480 phases, but were moved to the same phase. As I got into the 120 wiring, I discovered the neutrals were crisscrossed in several places. Some circuits even grabbed any convenient neutral, even out of the wrong panel. SMH...

          – Harper
          Apr 4 at 3:58














          Good answer. "Neutrals don't have fuses" is however not necessarily true. This depends on your local code. In general, just wanted to point out that the person asking (or other readers) might be from different countries with different regulations.

          – istepaniuk
          Apr 4 at 10:43





          Good answer. "Neutrals don't have fuses" is however not necessarily true. This depends on your local code. In general, just wanted to point out that the person asking (or other readers) might be from different countries with different regulations.

          – istepaniuk
          Apr 4 at 10:43













          @istepaniuk I would be keenly interested in hearing about any country that fuses neutrals as a contemporary practice. Other than the Phillippines... There are good reasons to not fuse neutral.

          – Harper
          Apr 4 at 14:57





          @istepaniuk I would be keenly interested in hearing about any country that fuses neutrals as a contemporary practice. Other than the Phillippines... There are good reasons to not fuse neutral.

          – Harper
          Apr 4 at 14:57

















          draft saved

          draft discarded
















































          Thanks for contributing an answer to Home Improvement Stack Exchange!


          • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

          But avoid


          • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

          • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

          To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




          draft saved


          draft discarded














          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fdiy.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f161304%2fcan-i-use-a-neutral-wire-from-another-outlet-to-repair-a-broken-neutral%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown





















































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown

































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown







          Popular posts from this blog

          Adding axes to figuresAdding axes labels to LaTeX figuresLaTeX equivalent of ConTeXt buffersRotate a node but not its content: the case of the ellipse decorationHow to define the default vertical distance between nodes?TikZ scaling graphic and adjust node position and keep font sizeNumerical conditional within tikz keys?adding axes to shapesAlign axes across subfiguresAdding figures with a certain orderLine up nested tikz enviroments or how to get rid of themAdding axes labels to LaTeX figures

          Tähtien Talli Jäsenet | Lähteet | NavigointivalikkoSuomen Hippos – Tähtien Talli

          Do these cracks on my tires look bad? The Next CEO of Stack OverflowDry rot tire should I replace?Having to replace tiresFishtailed so easily? Bad tires? ABS?Filling the tires with something other than air, to avoid puncture hassles?Used Michelin tires safe to install?Do these tyre cracks necessitate replacement?Rumbling noise: tires or mechanicalIs it possible to fix noisy feathered tires?Are bad winter tires still better than summer tires in winter?Torque converter failure - Related to replacing only 2 tires?Why use snow tires on all 4 wheels on 2-wheel-drive cars?